GP Institute of Australia · AGPT selection: the Casper SJT · Lesson 4 of 10

Autonomy and choice: consent, end of life, conscientious objection and vaccine hesitancy

Respect people’s right to decide, check that their decisions are informed and free, handle disagreement with families and colleagues, and stay respectful when a choice is one you would not make.

Reading time: about 35 minutes, plus 15 minutes of practiceNext scheduled review: Nov 2027
The current Casper format

The RACGP national entry assessment is Acuity Insights’ Casper test: 11 scenarios with two open-ended questions each, four answered on video (one minute per question) and seven typed (3.5 minutes for both questions). It assesses nine competencies, not clinical knowledge, so this lesson teaches judgement and communication rather than clinical facts.1

Where are you starting from?

Rate yourself honestly. There are no marks here; each “Not yet” or “Somewhat” points you to the part of this lesson that closes that gap.

I can explain decision-making capacity and why it is decision-specific.

Read section 1 →

I treat informed consent as a conversation, not a signature.

Read section 2 →

I can handle a family who disagrees with a patient’s advance care plan.

Read section 3 →

I can explain what a doctor with a conscientious objection must still do for the patient.

Read section 4 →

I can talk with a vaccine-hesitant parent respectfully, without lecturing.

Read section 5 →

“Not yet” answers: . Your choices are not saved.

Learning objectives

  • Explain capacity and the elements of valid consent, including for young people.
  • Respond to a refusal of treatment by exploring, informing and respecting.
  • Support advance care planning and manage family disagreement at the end of life.
  • Describe the ethical limits of conscientious objection for doctors.
  • Use a respectful, listening approach to vaccine hesitancy and other choices you disagree with.

How this shows up in Casper

  • Scenario types: a patient or friend refusing something you recommend; families disagreeing about end-of-life care; a colleague’s objection affecting a patient; a hesitant parent.
  • Typical question stems: “How would you respond to…?”, “How would you approach the conversation…?”, “What do you think of a policy that…?”
  • Common trap: trying to persuade or override instead of first understanding why the person has chosen as they have.
Study-priority stars
★★★★Must master: shapes almost every answer on this theme
★★★★High yield: frequent scenario types and common traps
★★★★Know the principles: background that sharpens your judgement
★★★★Background: context

Ratings are GP Institute’s editorial judgement, not an official RACGP or Acuity Insights weighting. Any competency can appear in any scenario.

Short on time? Read the ★★★★ sections first:

1. Autonomy and decision-making capacity ★★★★

Respect for autonomy means accepting that adults with capacity are entitled to make decisions about their own lives and bodies, including decisions others think unwise. It is one of the strongest values in modern medical ethics, and in Casper it extends naturally beyond medicine: friends, colleagues and family members also have the right to make their own choices.

Autonomy depends on capacity. Adults are presumed to have capacity unless there is reason to doubt it. Capacity is decision-specific (someone may be able to decide what to eat but not whether to sell their house) and time-specific (it can fluctuate with illness, medication or distress). Legal tests differ between Australian states and territories, but they share common elements.

Table 1. Common elements of decision-making capacity
ElementWhat you checkExample question
UnderstandCan the person understand the information relevant to the decision?“Can you tell me in your own words what we’ve discussed?”
RetainCan they hold onto it long enough to decide?“What were the main options again?”
Use and weighCan they weigh the options against their own values?“What matters most to you in making this choice?”
CommunicateCan they express a decision, by any means?Using interpreters, aids or written methods where needed

Teaching summary of widely used principles; the legal test depends on the jurisdiction.

Response pearl: an unwise decision is not proof of incapacity

A strong answer never assumes someone lacks capacity simply because they disagree with you. Say what would make you doubt capacity (confusion, inability to repeat the options back, a sudden change) and what you would do about it.

2. Informed consent as a conversation ★★★★

Valid consent needs three things: the person has capacity, the consent is voluntary (free of pressure from family, staff or circumstances), and it is informed. In Australia, the High Court’s decision in Rogers v Whitaker (1992) established that doctors must warn patients of material risks: risks a reasonable person in the patient’s position would likely consider significant, or that the doctor knows or should know this particular patient would consider significant.4 That patient-centred test is why consent is a conversation about what matters to this person, not a list read out and a form signed. Good medical practice describes informed consent as a person’s voluntary decision about health care, made with knowledge and understanding of the benefits and risks involved.2

Does the person have capacity for this decision?Presume yes in adults; check if there’s reason to doubt
Have they got the information that matters to them?Options (including doing nothing), benefits, material risks, uncertainty, in plain language
Is the decision free?Speak with them alone if pressure from others is possible
Yes to allRespect the decision, record the discussion, keep the door open
Doubt about anyAddress it: more information, time, an interpreter, a capacity assessment, a substitute decision-maker if needed
Figure 1. Checking that a decision is a valid one. GP Institute teaching framework. Casper point: raters reward answers that check these three things before either persuading or accepting.
Table 2. Special situations in consent
SituationPrincipleWhat a thoughtful answer includes
Emergency, patient unable to consentNecessary treatment can be given to save life or prevent serious harmTreat what is necessary; involve family; respect any known prior wishes
Young person under 18A young person who understands the decision fully may be able to consent for themselves (a “mature minor”); rules vary by stateAssess their understanding; encourage involving a parent; respect confidentiality where safe
Adult without capacityDecisions are made by a substitute decision-maker, guided by the person’s known values and any advance care directiveWho is the right decision-maker? What would the person have wanted?
Family pressureConsent must be the person’s ownSpeak with the person alone; use a professional interpreter rather than family
Language barrierInformation must be understood to be validProfessional interpreter; teach-back; written material in their language

2.1 When someone says no ★★★★

A refusal is not the end of the conversation; it is the start of understanding. People decline recommendations for many reasons: fear, cost, past experiences, cultural or religious values, practical barriers, misinformation, or a clear-eyed preference. A strong response explores the reasons, corrects misunderstandings, offers alternatives or compromises, and then, if the person still declines with capacity, respects the choice and leaves the door open. The weakest answers either give up immediately (“it’s her choice”) or keep pushing (“I would convince her”).

Response red flag: “I would convince them”

Your role is to make sure a choice is informed and free, not to win. Answers built around persuasion read as paternalistic. Answers that say “I’d understand why, make sure they had what they needed, and respect their decision” read as mature.

3. End-of-life care and advance care planning ★★★★

Good end-of-life care aims for comfort, dignity and care that matches what the person values. GPs are central to advance care planning: helping people think about, discuss and record their values and preferences for future care, and choose who would speak for them if they could not. Advance Care Planning Australia notes that the documents, names and legal status vary between states and territories, including advance care directives and the appointment of substitute decision-makers.5

Many Casper scenarios at the end of life are not really about medical decisions. They are about families: siblings who disagree, a relative who wants “everything done” despite the person’s wishes, guilt, grief, and old conflicts resurfacing. The skill is to keep the person’s own values at the centre while treating the family with compassion.

Table 3. Common end-of-life conflicts and a compassionate approach
ConflictWhat may be behind itApproach
Family wants everything done despite the person’s documented wishesGrief, guilt, not having been part of earlier conversationsMeet with the family; explain the person’s own words; acknowledge their love; focus on what the person wanted
Siblings disagreeDifferent relationships, information or values; distanceBring everyone together with the same information; identify the legal decision-maker; facilitate, don’t take sides
Family asks you not to tell the patientProtectiveness; cultural norms about bad newsAsk the patient how much they want to know and who should be involved (lesson 2)
Staff anxious about not transferring to hospitalFear of blame; unfamiliar with the planClarify the plan in writing; support staff; ensure comfort care is in place
What does the person want, and can they tell us now?If yes, ask them directly, with family present if they wish
If not: is there an advance care directive or documented plan?
Who is the substitute decision-maker?Appointed by the person, or as set by state law
Meet the family togetherShare the person’s own words; listen to grief and fears; agree a plan focused on comfort and dignity
Document, communicate to all carers, review
Figure 2. Keeping the person at the centre when families disagree. GP Institute teaching framework. Casper point: the question to return to is always “what would she have wanted?”, not “who argues hardest?”

3.1 Voluntary assisted dying ★★★★

Voluntary assisted dying (VAD) is now lawful in all six states and the ACT for eligible adults with a life-limiting illness, and each jurisdiction has its own eligibility rules and safeguards.6 The Northern Territory passed legislation in August 2026, with the scheme expected to start later.7 Casper does not test the law. What it may test is how you respond when a patient raises the subject, when colleagues disagree, or when your own values differ from the patient’s. Listen, avoid judgement, know the limits of your role, and make sure the person can reach accurate information.

4. Conscientious objection ★★★★

Doctors are people with consciences, and the profession accepts that a doctor may decline to provide or participate in some lawful treatments because of a sincere moral or religious objection, such as contraception, termination of pregnancy or VAD. But that right has limits, because the patient did not choose the doctor’s beliefs. Good medical practice expects doctors who object to be open about it, to inform patients (and relevant colleagues), and not to use the objection to impede patients’ access to lawful treatment.2 Some state laws add specific obligations, for example around providing information or referral for VAD.6

Table 4. What an objecting doctor should and should not do
ShouldShould not
Tell the patient early and respectfully that they don’t provide this serviceExpress judgement about the patient’s request
Make sure the patient can access the service elsewhere without delay, as required by law and the codeDelay, discourage or give misleading information
Continue all other careWithdraw from the patient’s care more broadly
Provide emergency care regardlessRefuse urgent care on conscience grounds
Let colleagues and the practice know in advance so systems can cover itLeave reception staff or colleagues to discover it in front of a patient
Response pearl: respect both consciences

Scenarios about a colleague’s objection test fairness on two sides. A strong answer respects the colleague’s right to their beliefs and protects the patient’s timely access to care, usually by a private conversation and a practice-level solution, not a public confrontation.

Build your experience bank

Think of a time you worked with someone whose values or beliefs differed strongly from yours. How did you keep the working relationship respectful, and what did you learn? This works for fairness, collaboration and self-awareness questions.

5. Vaccine hesitancy and choices you disagree with ★★★★

Vaccine hesitancy sits on a spectrum, from people with small questions to a small minority who refuse firmly. Most hesitant parents love their children and are trying to do the right thing with confusing information. The Australian Immunisation Handbook provides the national clinical guidance and resources for discussing vaccination with people who have concerns.8 In Casper, these scenarios test respect, listening and patience as much as knowledge.

Swipe to see the whole figure →

The hesitancy spectrum Accepts, with questions Answer clearly; check understanding Unsure or delaying Explore specific worries; offer trusted information; offer time and a follow-up Firmly refuses Respect the decision; keep the relationship; keep the door open At every point: listen first, avoid ridicule, and continue all other care.
Figure 3. Matching your approach to where someone sits. GP Institute teaching tool. Casper point: the relationship is the most important asset; a family who feels judged may stop coming at all.
Table 5. Helpful and unhelpful moves in a conversation about a contested choice
HelpfulUnhelpful
Asking what worries them most, and whyLaunching into statistics before listening
Acknowledging that they want the best for their childImplying they are irresponsible or foolish
Addressing their specific concern with clear, trusted informationDebunking every myth they didn’t raise
Offering time, written information and a follow-upDemanding a decision today
Continuing to care for the family whatever they decideThreatening to stop seeing them
Build your experience bank

Recall a time someone close to you made a choice you disagreed with. Did you try to change their mind? What worked, what didn’t, and how did you show respect for their right to choose? “Describe a time you supported someone whose decision you disagreed with” is a classic Casper question.

6. Worked scenarios

Try each scenario under the real time limit before you open the debrief. Your first instinct on the page is what you are training.

Scenario 1Typed · 3.5 minutes for both questions

EthicsCommunicationEmpathy

You are the GP registrar on call for a residential aged care facility on a Sunday afternoon. Mrs Edna Morris, 89, has advanced dementia and a chest infection; she is drowsy but comfortable. Her advance care directive, completed with her GP three years ago when she had capacity, says she does not want to be transferred to hospital and wants comfort-focused care at the facility.

Graham Morris (Mrs Morris’s son, who arrived from interstate this morning): I don’t care what that form says. Mum would want to fight. Call the ambulance; I’m not letting her die in here.

Linda Harris (facility manager): If the family wants transfer, we usually just send them. It’s safer for us if something goes wrong.

Priya Sharma (registered nurse, six months into the role): She’s settled at the moment. What do you want me to do?

  1. How would you respond to Graham?
  2. How would you address Linda’s concern about transfer?
Your turn. Set a timer for 3.5 minutes and answer both questions before opening the debrief.
Open the debrief

What is really going on

Mrs Morris’s own documented wishes conflict with her son’s request, and the facility’s instinct is to transfer for self-protection. Graham is likely grieving, perhaps guilty about being far away, and may not have been part of earlier conversations. Key questions: who is the legal substitute decision-maker, whether the directive is valid and applies to this situation, and whether her comfort needs can be met where she is.

Perspectives to acknowledge

  • Mrs Morris: her considered wishes, made with capacity, are the anchor.
  • Graham: love, fear, guilt, and possibly new to her decline.
  • Linda: worried about liability and procedure.
  • Priya: needs a clear, documented plan and support.

A reasonable approach

  1. Speak with Graham privately and with compassion; acknowledge how hard this is and how much he cares.
  2. Explain gently what his mother wrote and why, and that her wishes guide the decision; check whether he is the appointed substitute decision-maker and whether other family members are involved.
  3. Reassure him that comfort care is active care; explain what will be done to keep her comfortable, and invite him to stay with her.
  4. With Linda, confirm that following a valid advance care directive is the appropriate course, document the plan and the conversation clearly, and suggest support for staff.
  5. Give Priya clear orders for comfort care and when to call; arrange a review.
Weaker response pattern

“The advance directive is legally binding, so I’d tell Graham we can’t send her and that’s final. I’d tell Linda the family doesn’t get to decide.”

Correct anchor but cold; ignores Graham’s grief and doesn’t support staff or check facts.

Stronger response pattern

“I’d sit with Graham, acknowledge how hard this is, and share what his mum wrote when she was well and why. I’d explain comfort care is still active care and invite him to be with her. I’d check who her decision-maker is. With Linda I’d confirm we’re following a valid directive, document it carefully, and give Priya a clear plan.”

Compassionate, centres the patient’s own wishes, checks the legal facts, and supports staff.

These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.

Check your own response. Did you…

Ticked: of 5

Missed several? Re-read section 3 →
Scenario 2Typed · 3.5 minutes for both questions

CommunicationEmpathyEthics

Your close friend Aisha, 22, is in the final semester of an engineering degree. You have known her family for years.

Aisha tells you she has decided to leave university now, a semester short of finishing, to work full time on a sustainable fashion business she has started with two friends. The business has a few hundred customers but is not yet profitable. She says engineering was always her parents’ dream, not hers, and she feels she has to act now. Her parents, who migrated to Australia and worked long hours to support her education, are devastated. Her mother calls you and asks you to “talk some sense into her”, saying Aisha listens to you more than to them. Aisha has told you she will not change her mind.

  1. How would you respond to Aisha’s mother?
  2. How would you approach the conversation with Aisha?
Your turn. Set a timer for 3.5 minutes and answer both questions before opening the debrief.
Open the debrief

What is really going on

This is an autonomy scenario outside medicine. Aisha is an adult entitled to make her own life choices, even risky ones. Her parents’ distress is real and understandable, rooted in sacrifice and love. You are being asked to take sides in a family conflict. Unknowns: whether Aisha has considered options such as deferring rather than withdrawing, and how informed her decision is.

Perspectives to acknowledge

  • Aisha: wants to live her own life; may feel guilt as well as excitement.
  • Her parents: sacrifice, fear for her security, possibly feeling their efforts are being rejected.
  • You: friend to Aisha, trusted by her parents; at risk of being caught in the middle.

A reasonable approach

  1. Listen to her mother with empathy and acknowledge the sacrifices and love behind her worry.
  2. Be honest that you can’t persuade Aisha against her will, but that you can talk with her and encourage them to talk with each other.
  3. With Aisha, ask open questions: what draws her, what she has considered, whether deferring or finishing part-time is possible, how she would cope if it didn’t work.
  4. Respect her decision if she still chooses it; encourage her to explain her reasons to her parents with gratitude for what they did.
  5. Stay a support to both without becoming the messenger.
Weaker response pattern

“I’d agree with her mother that dropping out is a mistake and tell Aisha she should finish her degree first because it’s only one semester.”

Takes sides, disregards Aisha’s autonomy, and moves straight to persuasion.

Stronger response pattern

“I’d tell her mum I can hear how much they’ve sacrificed and how worried she is, but I can’t make Aisha’s decision for her. I’d talk with Aisha and ask what she’s weighed up, including whether she could defer. If she still chose the business, I’d respect it and encourage her to talk honestly with her parents about why.”

Empathetic to both, honest about your role, explores whether the choice is informed, respects autonomy, and builds a bridge.

These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.

Check your own response. Did you…

Ticked: of 5

Missed several? Re-read section 2.1 →
Scenario 3Video · 1 minute per question

CommunicationFairnessEmpathy

You are a GP registrar. Jess has brought her eight-week-old son, Noah, for his first scheduled vaccinations.

Once in the room, Jess says she has decided not to vaccinate Noah for now. She has read online that vaccines overload a baby’s immune system, and a friend’s child had a high fever after vaccination. She seems anxious and a little defensive, and says the last doctor she saw “made her feel like an idiot”. Your supervisor has mentioned that some practices in the area have started declining to see families who choose not to vaccinate, and has asked the registrars what they think.

  1. How would you respond to Jess?
  2. What do you think of a practice declining to see families who choose not to vaccinate?
Your turn. Record yourself on your phone: one minute for question 1, then one minute for question 2, without stopping in between. Use the box for notes if you like.
Open the debrief

What is really going on

A hesitant, anxious parent who has felt judged before. The first priority is the relationship: if she feels dismissed again, Noah may lose access to care altogether. Her concerns are specific and can be explored. The second question is a values question about a policy: it pits community protection and staff frustration against access to care for children who did not make the choice.

Perspectives to acknowledge

  • Jess: wants to protect her son; anxious; past bad experience.
  • Noah: the most vulnerable person, dependent on adults’ decisions.
  • Other patients: including infants too young to be vaccinated in the waiting room.
  • The practice: wants to promote vaccination and protect others.

A reasonable approach

  1. Thank her for coming and for being open; acknowledge she is trying to do the best for Noah.
  2. Ask what worries her most; address her specific concerns (immune load, fever) with clear, trusted information, such as the Australian Immunisation Handbook and its parent resources.
  3. Offer time, written information and a follow-up appointment; there is no need to force a decision today.
  4. Continue all other care for Noah regardless of her decision.
  5. On the policy: weigh the reasons for it, but note that excluding families harms children who didn’t choose, removes the chance to keep talking, and may push them away from care; suggest alternatives such as practical measures to protect vulnerable patients in the waiting room.
Weaker response pattern

“I’d explain that vaccines are proven safe and that not vaccinating puts other children at risk, so she should really go ahead today. I think the policy is fair because it protects others.”

Lectures before listening, pushes for an immediate decision, and endorses a policy without weighing its harm to the child.

Stronger response pattern

“I’d thank Jess for being honest and say I can see she’s trying to protect Noah. I’d ask what worries her most, then talk through the fever and immune questions, with trusted information to take home. No decision needed today; I’d book a follow-up and keep caring for Noah either way. I’d be cautious about the policy, because it punishes children for their parents’ choices and ends the conversation.”

Listens first, specific, respectful, keeps the relationship, and gives a balanced view of the policy.

These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.

Check your own response. Did you…

Ticked: of 5

Missed several? Re-read section 5 →
Response-readiness check

Tick each item you could do in a real Casper sitting without looking back at this lesson.

Ready: of 7. Your ticks are not saved.

7. Key takeaways

Key takeaways
  • Adults are presumed to have capacity; capacity is decision-specific and can fluctuate.
  • An unwise decision is not proof of incapacity.
  • Valid consent needs capacity, voluntariness and the information that matters to this person (material risks, per Rogers v Whitaker).
  • Speak with a person alone when pressure from others is possible, and use professional interpreters rather than family.
  • A refusal is the start of understanding: explore, inform, offer alternatives, then respect.
  • Advance care planning keeps the person’s own values at the centre when they can no longer speak for themselves.
  • When families disagree at the end of life, return to “what would she have wanted?” and treat the family with compassion.
  • A conscientious objector must be open about it, must not impede lawful access, and must continue other and emergency care.
  • Vaccine hesitancy is a spectrum: listen first, address specific concerns, keep the relationship and the door open.
  • Your aim is an informed, free choice, not winning the argument.

Practice plan

WhenTask
TodayComplete the three worked scenarios under time
Day 3Practise the capacity, information and voluntariness check aloud on two practice scenarios
Day 7Four typed and two video scenarios on refusal, family disagreement and objection
Day 14Add a “supporting a choice I disagreed with” entry to your experience bank
Week before your testMixed timed set; check no answer is built on persuasion

Your next step

Choose the line that matches your self-ratings and scenario self-checks in this lesson.

Two or more “Not yet” ratings, or under half ticked on most scenario self-checks: go back to the core approach before moving on.Re-read section 2
Most self-checks more than half ticked: you have the approach; build speed with more timed scenarios on this theme.Practise more scenarios
Every self-check fully or almost fully ticked and readiness all ticked: move on to lesson 5 (when things go wrong).Sit a timed mock

References

  1. Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. National entry assessment. https://www.racgp.org.au/a-career-in-general-practice/become-a-gp/national-entry-assessment (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
  2. Medical Board of Australia. Good medical practice: a code of conduct for doctors in Australia (effective 1 October 2020). https://www.medicalboard.gov.au/Codes-Guidelines-Policies/Code-of-conduct (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
  3. Australian Medical Association. AMA Code of Ethics 2025. https://www.ama.com.au/sites/default/files/2026-02/AMA_Code_of_Ethics_2025.pdf (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
  4. Rogers v Whitaker (1992) 175 CLR 479, High Court of Australia.
  5. Advance Care Planning Australia. Advance care planning: laws and documents in each state and territory. https://www.advancecareplanning.org.au (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
  6. Townend S, Burns P. Voluntary assisted dying: key information for Australian general practitioners. Aust J Gen Pract 2026;55(6). https://www1.racgp.org.au/ajgp/2026/june/voluntary-assisted-dying (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
  7. Queensland University of Technology. The Northern Territory has just voted to legalise voluntary assisted dying. Here’s how it will work (2026). https://www.qut.edu.au/news/realfocus/the-northern-territory-has-just-voted-to-legalise-voluntary-assisted-dying.-heres-how-it-will-work (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
  8. Australian Government Department of Health. Australian Immunisation Handbook. https://immunisationhandbook.health.gov.au (accessed 17 Nov 2026).

Recommended reading

  • Medical Board of Australia, Good medical practice: sections on informed consent and conscientious objection.2
  • Advance Care Planning Australia: the guide for your state or territory.5
  • Voluntary assisted dying: key information for Australian general practitioners (AJGP 2026).6
  • Australian Immunisation Handbook: sections on talking with people about vaccination.8
Casper is a registered trademark of Acuity Insights. GP Institute of Australia is independent and is not affiliated with, endorsed by or connected to Acuity Insights, the RACGP or ACRRM. Scenarios in this lesson are original and fictional; any resemblance to real people or events is coincidental. This lesson is educational and is not legal advice; laws differ between states and territories.
© 2026 GP Institute of Australia. For personal study only. Not to be reproduced without permission.
Scroll to Top