GP Institute of Australia · AGPT selection: the Casper SJT · Lesson 7 of 10
Teams and leadership: collaboration, delegation, conflict and leading without a title
Work well with every member of the practice team, hand over and delegate safely, resolve conflict early and respectfully, and show leadership whatever your position.
The RACGP national entry assessment is Acuity Insights’ Casper test: 11 scenarios with two open-ended questions each, four answered on video (one minute per question) and seven typed (3.5 minutes for both questions). It assesses nine competencies, not clinical knowledge, so this lesson teaches judgement and communication rather than clinical facts.1
Where are you starting from?
Rate yourself honestly. There are no marks here; each “Not yet” or “Somewhat” points you to the part of this lesson that closes that gap.
I can name the roles in a general practice team and how each contributes.
I can give a structured handover or raise a concern with another professional clearly.
I know what I can safely delegate and what remains my responsibility.
I can address a conflict between colleagues early and fairly.
I can show leadership as a registrar, not only as a practice owner.
“Not yet” answers: . Your choices are not saved.
Learning objectives
- Describe the general practice team and respect every member’s contribution.
- Use structured, respectful interprofessional communication, including ISBAR.
- Delegate and supervise safely, and ask for help as a supervisee.
- Resolve team conflict early, privately and fairly, and act on bullying.
- Demonstrate leadership through behaviour, not title.
How this shows up in Casper
- Scenario types: a disagreement between colleagues; a senior belittling a junior; an unfair workload in a group; a task delegated beyond someone’s competence; a team that isn’t working.
- Typical question stems: “How would you address the conflict…?”, “How would you respond to the plan…?”, “Describe a time you led…”
- Common trap: taking sides, taking over, or treating non-medical staff as less important.
| ★★★★ | Must master: shapes almost every answer on this theme |
| ★★★★ | High yield: frequent scenario types and common traps |
| ★★★★ | Know the principles: background that sharpens your judgement |
| ★★★★ | Background: context |
Ratings are GP Institute’s editorial judgement, not an official RACGP or Acuity Insights weighting. Any competency can appear in any scenario.
1. The general practice team ★★★★
General practice is a team activity. A single patient’s care may involve receptionists, practice nurses, the practice manager, GPs and registrars, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health workers and practitioners, pharmacists, allied health professionals, specialists and hospital teams. Good medical practice expects doctors to work collaboratively, communicate clearly and treat colleagues with respect.2 In Casper, many scenarios put you in a team, and raters notice whether you value people’s contributions regardless of their title.
| Role | What they bring | How to work well with them |
|---|---|---|
| Receptionist | First contact; knows patients and the community; manages flow | Clear protocols; backing in difficult situations; never blame them for system problems |
| Practice nurse | Chronic disease care, immunisation, wound care, health checks; often long patient relationships | Listen to concerns; share decisions; respect their scope |
| Practice manager | Systems, staff, finances, compliance | Raise system issues constructively; recognise competing pressures |
| Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health worker or practitioner | Cultural knowledge, community connection, clinical skills | Seek their advice; involve them early (lesson 8) |
| Pharmacist | Medication expertise; may spot errors or interactions | Welcome queries; respond promptly |
| Allied health and specialists | Expert assessment and treatment | Clear referrals; follow up; resolve disagreements professionally |
| Supervisor | Experience, teaching, oversight | Ask early; be honest about uncertainty |
2. Interprofessional communication ★★★★
Poor communication between health professionals is a leading contributor to adverse events. The Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care promotes structured clinical handover, and one widely used structure is ISBAR: identify, situation, background, assessment, recommendation.3 Structure matters most when you are worried and in a hurry, which is exactly when people communicate badly.
| Situation | Constructive approach |
|---|---|
| A pharmacist questions your prescription | Thank them; check; change it if they’re right; explain if not; never take it personally |
| A specialist’s plan seems wrong for your patient | Call to discuss, with your reasons; involve the patient; seek another opinion if needed |
| A nurse raises a concern with your plan | Listen fully; reconsider; explain your reasoning; agree a plan |
| Disagreeing with your supervisor | Ask about their reasoning first; share yours respectfully; escalate only for safety |
When someone questions your decision, the strongest answers start with gratitude, not defence: “I’d thank her for checking.” A team where people feel safe to question each other is a safer team.
3. Delegation and supervision ★★★★
Delegation lets a team use everyone’s skills well, but the person who delegates keeps responsibility for the decision to delegate and for providing adequate instruction and oversight. Good medical practice expects doctors to delegate only to people who are competent to do the task, and to remain responsible for the overall management of the patient.2 A simple checklist, adapted from nursing practice, is the “five rights” of delegation.
| Right | Question to ask |
|---|---|
| Right task | Is this something that can be delegated, within policy and law? |
| Right person | Do they have the training, competence and scope of practice? |
| Right instructions | Have I been clear about what, how, when and what to do if something goes wrong? |
| Right supervision | Am I available? Will I check? |
| Right review | Will I review the outcome and give feedback? |
As a GP registrar you will also be supervised. Good supervisees ask for help early, are honest about uncertainty, and don’t hide mistakes. “I’m not sure” is a professional statement, not a weakness. Casper scenarios sometimes test whether you recognise the limits of your own competence and seek advice rather than guessing.
| Situation | What a good supervisee does |
|---|---|
| Unsure of a diagnosis or plan | Asks before acting, with a clear summary and a question |
| Made a mistake | Tells the supervisor promptly and helps put it right (lesson 5) |
| Supervisor unavailable | Uses the backup supervisor or the practice’s escalation plan; doesn’t guess |
| Disagrees with the supervisor | Asks about their reasoning, shares their own respectfully; escalates only for safety |
| Struggling with workload or wellbeing | Raises it early, before it affects patients |
Think of a time you were asked to do something you didn’t feel ready for, or a time you supervised or taught someone. What did you do to make it safe? Delegation and supervision questions often appear as “describe a time” prompts.
4. Resolving team conflict ★★★★
Conflict in teams is normal; unresolved conflict is harmful. It erodes trust, drives people out, and creates the silence in which errors happen. Most team conflicts arise from workload, role confusion, communication style, personality, or perceived unfairness. Early, private, curious conversations solve most of them. Some behaviours are not “conflict” at all: bullying, harassment and discrimination are unacceptable and need to be addressed directly, and Good medical practice expects doctors not to engage in or ignore them.2
Swipe to see the whole figure →
When a senior belittles a junior in front of others, saying nothing communicates that it’s acceptable. A strong answer protects the person in the moment, without humiliating anyone, and then raises it privately.
5. Leadership without a title ★★★★
Leadership in general practice is not only for practice owners. Registrars lead when they coordinate a patient’s care, teach a medical student, suggest a better recall system, model respectful behaviour or speak up about safety. Casper often asks you to “describe a time you showed leadership”; the best examples are often small and specific rather than grand titles.
| Behaviour | What it looks like for a registrar |
|---|---|
| Setting direction | Proposing a clear plan in a team discussion |
| Supporting others | Checking in on a struggling colleague; backing reception staff |
| Modelling standards | Being on time, respectful, honest about mistakes |
| Improving systems | Suggesting a change after an incident and helping implement it |
| Sharing credit, owning failure | “The nurse noticed it first”; “that was my error” |
| Listening | Asking quieter team members for their view |
“I was captain of the hockey team” is a title. “I noticed our handover sheet kept missing pending results, so I drafted a new one, asked the nurses for feedback and got the team to trial it” is leadership. Raters reward the second.
The RACGP’s Standards for general practices, whose sixth edition was released in August 2026, emphasise governance, quality improvement and consumer engagement as shared responsibilities across the practice team.4 You do not need to know the standards for Casper, but the direction is clear: good practices are led collectively, and everyone contributes to quality and safety.
Choose a leadership example where you had no formal authority: perhaps you organised a ward roster swap fairly, improved a handover sheet, or got a stalled project moving. What did you do, how did you bring others with you, and what did you learn about leading?
6. Worked scenarios
Try each scenario under the real time limit before you open the debrief. Your first instinct on the page is what you are training.
CollaborationEthicsCommunication
You are a GP registrar. In the treatment room, the practice nurse is preparing an injection ordered by a senior GP for a patient. A student nurse on placement is observing.
Aroha Walker (practice nurse with 15 years’ experience): Before I give this, the patient has just told me she had a reaction to this medication last year. Should we check her record first?
Dr Graham Stokes (senior GP and practice partner, in the doorway): For goodness’ sake, I don’t need a nurse second-guessing me. Just give it; I’m running late.
Lily Chen (student nurse on placement, quietly to you afterwards): Is that normal here? I’d never feel able to say anything after seeing that.
- How would you respond in the moment?
- How would you address Dr Stokes’s behaviour afterwards?
Open the debrief
What is really going on
Two issues, in priority order: a possible allergy that needs checking before the injection (patient safety), and a senior colleague belittling a nurse for raising it, witnessed by a student who is learning that speaking up is punished. You have less authority than Dr Stokes but real influence.
Perspectives to acknowledge
- The patient: at possible risk; entitled to a safe check.
- Aroha: did exactly the right thing and was humiliated.
- Dr Stokes: under time pressure; probably not intending harm; still responsible for his behaviour.
- Lily: learning team norms; needs to know speaking up is right.
A reasonable approach
- Support the safety check immediately: calmly suggest a quick look at the record before the injection; take responsibility for checking if helpful.
- Back Aroha in the moment, without confronting Dr Stokes publicly.
- Afterwards, thank Aroha and check she’s okay; tell Lily clearly that Aroha did the right thing.
- Speak with Dr Stokes privately and respectfully: acknowledge his pressure, describe the impact, and the importance of nurses feeling safe to question.
- If the behaviour is part of a pattern, raise it with the practice principal or through the practice’s processes.
“Dr Stokes is the senior doctor, so I’d let Aroha decide. Afterwards I’d report him to the practice manager for bullying.”
Leaves the safety risk unaddressed and skips a direct conversation.
“I’d say calmly, ‘Let’s take thirty seconds to check her record first; I’ll look it up now.’ Afterwards I’d thank Aroha and tell Lily that checking was exactly right. Then I’d find a private moment with Dr Stokes, acknowledge he was rushed, but explain how it landed and why we need nurses to feel safe to question us. If it kept happening, I’d raise it with the principal.”
Safety first, supports the nurse and student, gives private feedback with empathy, and escalates proportionately.
These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.
Ticked: of 5
FairnessCollaborationProblem-solving
Outside work, you lead a team of four volunteers rebuilding a community garden for a local primary school. The opening, with the school community invited, is in three weeks.
Two team members, Sarah and Jordan, have stopped speaking to each other after Jordan publicly criticised Sarah’s planting plan at a meeting. Sarah has since done most of the heavy work on her own and told you privately she feels “taken for granted and talked over”. Jordan says Sarah “never listens to anyone else’s ideas” and has stopped coming to working bees. The fourth member, Tom, has said he’ll quit if the tension continues. The school principal has emailed asking whether the garden will be ready on time.
- How would you address the conflict between Sarah and Jordan?
- How would you make sure the workload is shared fairly?
Open the debrief
What is really going on
A team conflict with a workload imbalance and a deadline. Both Sarah and Jordan have legitimate grievances: Sarah’s effort is unrecognised and Jordan felt unheard. As leader you need to hear both, avoid taking sides, and restructure the work, while keeping the principal informed honestly.
Perspectives to acknowledge
- Sarah: overworked, unappreciated, hurt by public criticism.
- Jordan: felt his ideas were dismissed; withdrew.
- Tom: discouraged by the atmosphere.
- The school: needs a realistic timeline.
A reasonable approach
- Speak with Sarah and Jordan separately, listen to each, and acknowledge their feelings.
- Bring them together with a focus on the shared goal (the children’s garden); agree respectful ways to disagree, such as discussing ideas before meetings.
- Recognise Sarah’s contribution openly.
- Redistribute tasks clearly with names and dates; check Tom is engaged.
- Update the principal honestly about progress and any adjustment needed.
- Follow up in a week.
“I’d tell Jordan he was out of line criticising Sarah in public, and that if he can’t work with the team he should leave.”
Takes sides without hearing Jordan, and risks losing a volunteer without fixing the workload.
“I’d meet each of them separately to hear their side, then bring them together around the kids’ garden and agree how we’d raise disagreements. I’d thank Sarah openly for carrying so much, then set out a task list with names and dates so the load is shared. I’d give the principal an honest update and check in with everyone next week.”
Hears both sides, focuses on shared goals, recognises effort, structures fairness, and communicates upward.
These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.
Ticked: of 5
Problem-solvingCollaborationSelf-awareness
You are a GP registrar. The practice is under pressure with long phone queues.
At a staff meeting, the practice manager, Deb, proposes that receptionists start deciding over the phone whether callers with symptoms such as chest pain, shortness of breath or a sick baby need an urgent appointment, an ambulance or a routine booking, so that doctors are interrupted less. The receptionists have no clinical training and no written guidance. After the meeting one receptionist, Fatima, tells you privately that she’s worried about getting it wrong but doesn’t want to look unhelpful.
- How would you respond to Deb’s plan?
- Describe a time you were asked to take on a task you didn’t feel ready for.
Open the debrief
What is really going on
A delegation problem: a task requiring clinical judgement is being given to people without the training, protocols or supervision to do it safely. The underlying problem (phone pressure) is real and deserves a solution. Fatima’s concern is valid and needs to be raised without exposing her.
Perspectives to acknowledge
- Callers: some could be seriously unwell.
- Receptionists: asked to carry clinical risk without training; afraid to object.
- Deb: trying to solve a real workload problem.
- Doctors and nurses: interruptions affect their care too.
A reasonable approach
- Acknowledge the problem Deb is trying to solve.
- Raise the safety concern: deciding urgency for red-flag symptoms needs clinical judgement; without training and protocols it puts patients and staff at risk.
- Suggest safer alternatives: a written red-flag list telling reception to put such calls straight through to a nurse or doctor, or advise calling 000; a nurse triage line; training.
- Support Fatima without naming her; offer to help draft the protocol.
- For question 2, give a specific, honest example with what you did to make it safe.
“It’s the practice manager’s decision, so I’d go along with it, and tell Fatima to just send anyone who sounds sick to hospital to be safe.”
Accepts unsafe delegation and gives Fatima an unworkable rule.
“I’d say I understand the phone pressure, but deciding urgency for chest pain or a sick baby needs clinical judgement, and it isn’t fair or safe to put that on reception without training. Instead I’d suggest a simple red-flag list that goes straight to a nurse or doctor, or 000, and offer to help write it. For question 2, I’d describe my first solo night shift and how I asked for help early.”
Respectful, names the safety issue, offers a practical alternative, supports staff, and gives a reflective personal example.
These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.
Ticked: of 5
Tick each item you could do in a real Casper sitting without looking back at this lesson.
- Not yet? Re-read section 1 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 2 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 2 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 3 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 4 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 4 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 5 →
Ready: of 7. Your ticks are not saved.
7. Key takeaways
- General practice is a team; value every role, especially non-medical staff.
- Structured communication (such as ISBAR) is most important when you’re worried and in a hurry.
- Welcome challenge: thank the person who questions your decision.
- The person who delegates keeps responsibility: right task, person, instructions, supervision, review.
- As a supervisee, ask early and be honest about uncertainty.
- Address conflict early, privately and with curiosity; hear both sides before judging.
- Bullying, harassment and discrimination are not “conflict”; act on them.
- Never stay silent while a colleague is belittled; protect in the moment, give feedback privately.
- Collaborating is usually the target style; avoiding and competing are the commonest weak answers.
- Leadership is behaviour, not title: small, specific examples are strongest.
Practice plan
| When | Task |
|---|---|
| Today | Complete the three worked scenarios under time |
| Day 3 | Write an ISBAR escalation for a made-up worry and say it aloud in under 45 seconds |
| Day 7 | Four typed and two video scenarios on team conflict and delegation |
| Day 14 | Add a ‘leadership without a title’ and a ‘task I wasn’t ready for’ entry to your experience bank |
| Week before your test | Mixed timed set; check no answer takes sides before hearing both |
Your next step
Choose the line that matches your self-ratings and scenario self-checks in this lesson.
References
- Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. National entry assessment. https://www.racgp.org.au/a-career-in-general-practice/become-a-gp/national-entry-assessment (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Medical Board of Australia. Good medical practice: a code of conduct for doctors in Australia (effective 1 October 2020). https://www.medicalboard.gov.au/Codes-Guidelines-Policies/Code-of-conduct (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care. Clinical handover (Communicating for Safety). https://www.safetyandquality.gov.au/our-work/communicating-safety/clinical-handover (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. Standards for general practices, 6th edition (released 26 August 2026). https://www.racgp.org.au/running-a-practice/practice-standards/standards-6th-edition/standards-6th-edition-hub (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
Recommended reading
Ethical dilemmas are a common challenge in general practice, and understanding how to manage them is a key component of the Situational Judgement Test (SJT) for GP selection. As a future GP, you will encounter situations where there is no clear-cut right or wrong answer, and your ability to navigate these dilemmas while adhering to ethical principles is essential. The SJT assesses how well you can approach these complex situations with professionalism, integrity, and a patient-centered mindset.
Understanding Ethical Dilemmas in General Practice
Ethical dilemmas in general practice often arise when the interests of patients, healthcare professionals, and other stakeholders (such as family members or the healthcare system) conflict. For example, a patient might refuse a life-saving treatment based on their personal beliefs, or there may be a conflict between maintaining patient confidentiality and the need to inform authorities about a potential public health risk. In these situations, the right course of action is not always clear. The SJT tests your ability to weigh competing ethical principles and make decisions that prioritize patient welfare, respect autonomy, and uphold professional standards.
In the SJT, you may be presented with scenarios that involve ethical dilemmas, such as balancing the autonomy of a patient with the need for intervention, managing requests for unnecessary treatments, or navigating the complexities of informed consent. It’s important to recognize that while these dilemmas might seem challenging, they often require you to take a step back, consider the context, and apply your understanding of ethical principles to arrive at the best decision.
Key Ethical Principles in Dealing with Dilemmas
There are several core ethical principles that guide decision-making in general practice, and these are the principles that will inform your responses to ethical dilemmas in the SJT.
- Autonomy: This principle emphasizes respecting the patient’s right to make their own decisions about their care, even if those decisions go against medical advice. In the SJT, you may face situations where a patient refuses a treatment you believe to be in their best interest. While it’s essential to respect their autonomy, you must also ensure they are fully informed and understand the potential consequences of their decision.
- Beneficence: This principle involves acting in the best interest of the patient and promoting their well-being. In ethical dilemmas, this may require balancing patient autonomy with the need to offer the most appropriate treatment. In some cases, you may need to take a proactive approach to ensure the patient receives the care they need, while still respecting their wishes.
- Non-maleficence: This principle is rooted in the idea of “do no harm.” In the context of ethical dilemmas, it means avoiding actions that could cause harm to the patient. For example, prescribing unnecessary medications or treatments that could have adverse side effects would violate this principle. The SJT assesses your ability to avoid harm while navigating complex ethical scenarios.
- Justice: This principle involves fairness and equality in the delivery of healthcare. In practice, it means ensuring that all patients have access to the same level of care, regardless of their background, financial status, or other factors. Ethical dilemmas in general practice may require you to balance the needs of individual patients with those of the broader community.
Practical Approaches to Ethical Dilemmas
When faced with an ethical dilemma in general practice, it’s important to approach the situation systematically. The SJT evaluates your ability to respond to these challenges in a thoughtful and well-reasoned way. Here are some practical approaches to handling ethical dilemmas:
- Assess the Situation: Take time to fully understand the problem. Gather all relevant information, including the patient’s wishes, medical history, and the potential risks and benefits of different courses of action. In the SJT, you’ll often need to analyze the scenario carefully before making a decision.
- Consult Ethical Guidelines: In general practice, ethical guidelines from professional bodies such as the Medical Board of Australia, the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (RACGP), and other relevant organizations provide guidance on how to approach dilemmas. Familiarize yourself with these principles as they will inform your responses in the SJT.
- Involve the Patient: In many ethical dilemmas, involving the patient in the decision-making process is crucial. Make sure they understand the situation, the risks involved, and their options. In the SJT, you’ll be assessed on your ability to communicate with patients effectively and to involve them in decisions about their care. Remember, informed consent is key.
- Seek Support: In complex or high-stakes ethical dilemmas, it’s important to seek advice from colleagues, supervisors, or an ethics committee. This is particularly relevant in situations where you might be unsure of the best course of action. The SJT might present you with a scenario in which seeking guidance from a senior professional is the most appropriate response.
- Consider the Bigger Picture: Ethical dilemmas often involve balancing competing priorities, such as the needs of the patient versus the demands of the healthcare system. Think about the long-term implications of your decisions for both the individual patient and the broader community.
Examples of Ethical Dilemmas in General Practice
In the SJT, you may encounter scenarios involving ethical dilemmas such as:
- End-of-Life Care: A patient with a terminal illness may wish to discontinue treatment or enter palliative care. As their GP, you might believe that continuing treatment is in their best interest, but respecting their autonomy and ensuring they have all the information to make an informed decision is crucial.
- Confidentiality: A patient discloses information that could pose a risk to others, such as a communicable disease or abuse. You must decide whether to maintain confidentiality or breach it to protect others. This decision requires careful consideration of ethical principles and legal requirements.
- Resource Allocation: In situations where healthcare resources are limited, such as during a pandemic or a shortage of essential medications, you may face ethical dilemmas about how to allocate resources fairly and equitably.
In conclusion, dealing with ethical dilemmas is an essential skill for general practitioners and is a key component of the Situational Judgement Test (SJT). The SJT assesses your ability to navigate these complex scenarios while prioritizing patient welfare, adhering to ethical guidelines, and making decisions that are fair and just. By understanding the core ethical principles and applying them thoughtfully to the situations presented in the SJT, you can demonstrate your readiness to handle the ethical challenges of general practice. Always approach ethical dilemmas with empathy, respect, and professionalism, ensuring that the needs of the patient are at the forefront of your decision-making.