GP Institute of Australia · AGPT selection: the Casper SJT · Lesson 2 of 10

Competencies and ethical reasoning: making tough calls visible

Turn the nine Casper competencies and the core principles of medical ethics into a reasoning process you can show, in writing or on camera, within the time limit.

Reading time: about 35 minutes, plus 15 minutes of practiceNext scheduled review: Nov 2027
The current Casper format

The RACGP national entry assessment is Acuity Insights’ Casper test: 11 scenarios with two open-ended questions each, four answered on video (one minute per question) and seven typed (3.5 minutes for both questions). It assesses nine competencies, not clinical knowledge, so this lesson teaches judgement and communication rather than clinical facts.1

Where are you starting from?

Rate yourself honestly. There are no marks here; each “Not yet” or “Somewhat” points you to the part of this lesson that closes that gap.

I can show each of the nine competencies through what I write, not by naming it.

Read section 1 →

I can explain autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice with a non-clinical example of each.

Read section 2 →

When two values conflict, I can name the conflict in one sentence before I decide.

Read section 3 →

I have a step-by-step process for a dilemma that I could use under time pressure.

Read section 4 →

I know how to show a position without sounding preachy or absolute.

Read section 6 →

“Not yet” answers: . Your choices are not saved.

Learning objectives

  • Map the nine RACGP competencies onto observable behaviours in an answer.
  • Apply the four principles, plus honesty and professionalism, to clinical and everyday dilemmas.
  • Recognise the common value conflicts that Casper scenarios are built on.
  • Use a five-step dilemma process and four quick tests to check your decision.
  • Prioritise competing issues so safety and the most vulnerable person come first.

How this shows up in Casper

  • Scenario types: dilemmas where two good values pull in opposite directions: honesty and kindness, loyalty and fairness, a person’s choice and their safety.
  • Typical question stems: “How would you respond to…?”, “What would you consider when deciding…?”, “Is it ever acceptable to…?”
  • Common trap: picking a side in the first line, or sitting on the fence for the whole answer.
Study-priority stars
★★★★Must master: shapes almost every answer on this theme
★★★★High yield: frequent scenario types and common traps
★★★★Know the principles: background that sharpens your judgement
★★★★Background: context

Ratings are GP Institute’s editorial judgement, not an official RACGP or Acuity Insights weighting. Any competency can appear in any scenario.

1. From competencies to behaviours ★★★★

The RACGP lists nine competencies that the national entry assessment measures: collaboration, communication, empathy, fairness, ethics, self-awareness, resilience, problem-solving and motivation.1 Raters never see a box labelled “empathy”. They read what you wrote, or watch what you said, and judge whether the response as a whole shows sound judgement. So the competencies are not words to drop into an answer (“I would show empathy”). They are behaviours that should be visible in what you would actually do.

Older preparation materials, including earlier versions of this course, listed sixteen or more “competencies” such as leadership, prioritisation, cultural competence, integrity and time management. Those qualities still matter, but they are not separate scoring categories. Each one is a way of showing one or more of the nine. Table 1 makes the link, so that you can stop worrying about the list and start practising the behaviours.

Table 1. The nine RACGP competencies and the behaviours that show them
CompetencyBehaviours a rater can seeRelated qualities from older lists
CollaborationInvolving the right people; sharing decisions; acknowledging others’ expertiseTeamwork, collaboration beyond health care, leadership
CommunicationSaying what you would actually say; choosing a private setting; open questions; plain languageInterpersonal skills, patient-centred communication
EmpathyNaming how each person probably feels and why, including the person who seems to be in the wrongPatient-centred care, compassion
FairnessApplying the same standard to everyone, or justifying an exception; noticing who is disadvantagedEquity, social responsibility, cultural competence
EthicsNaming competing values, weighing them openly, acting with honesty and integrityIntegrity, professionalism, quality of care
Self-awarenessRecognising your own limits, biases and part in a problem; seeking adviceSelf-reflection and learning
ResilienceStaying constructive after a setback; describing what you changedAdaptability, situational adaptability
Problem-solvingGathering information first; weighing options and consequences; proportionate actionDecision-making, prioritisation, time and resource management
MotivationLinking choices to genuine reasons for wanting to practise as a GP, with specificsCommitment, professional growth

Competency names are from the RACGP.1 The behaviours and the mapping are GP Institute’s teaching summary.

Response pearl: show, don’t label

“I would be empathetic” tells the rater nothing. “I’d acknowledge that she’s probably embarrassed and worried about her job” shows empathy. Replace every competency word in your practice answers with the behaviour it stands for.

2. The principles of medical ethics, and why they work outside medicine ★★★★

The four principles described by Beauchamp and Childress, respect for autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice, remain the most widely used framework for reasoning about ethical problems in health care.4 They are not a formula. They are a checklist of the values most often at stake, which makes them ideal for Casper: in 30 seconds of reflection you can ask which of them are in tension.

They also work outside medicine. Casper sets many scenarios in workplaces, schools, sports clubs and families, and the same principles apply: respecting a friend’s choice (autonomy), helping a colleague (beneficence), not making a situation worse (non-maleficence), treating team members fairly (justice). Honesty and professionalism sit alongside them as values that almost every scenario touches.

Table 2. Core ethical principles with a general practice and an everyday example
PrincipleIn plain languageGeneral practice exampleEveryday Casper example
Respect for autonomyPeople with capacity decide for themselves, with the information they needA patient declines a recommended referral after a full discussionA friend chooses to leave a stable job for a risky venture
BeneficenceAct for the other person’s goodFollowing up a patient who missed an important appointmentOffering to help a struggling colleague with a deadline
Non-maleficenceAvoid causing harm, including harm from acting too drasticallyNot ordering tests that cause anxiety without benefitNot confronting someone publicly when a private word would do
JusticeFair distribution of benefits, burdens and attentionAllocating scarce same-day appointments by need, not by who pushes hardestSharing overtime fairly across a team
HonestyTruthfulness and not misleading by omissionTelling a patient about an error in their careAdmitting you missed a deadline rather than blaming a system
ConfidentialityInformation shared in trust stays protectedNot discussing a patient with their relative without consentKeeping a friend’s disclosure private unless someone is at risk
ProfessionalismIntegrity, accountability and putting duties before self-interestDeclaring a conflict of interestKeeping commitments as a volunteer even when inconvenient

2.1 Principles are tools, not trump cards ★★★★

A common mistake is to treat one principle as automatically winning: “autonomy is paramount, so I would respect his decision” or “patient safety always comes first”. Real dilemmas exist precisely because each principle has weight. A strong answer shows the weighing: autonomy matters a great deal, and it depends on capacity and on the person having accurate information; safety matters a great deal, and overriding someone’s choice causes its own harm. Showing that you feel the pull of both sides is the clearest sign of ethical maturity a rater can see.

2.2 Where Australian professional codes fit ★★★★

For Australian doctors, the Medical Board of Australia’s Good medical practice: a code of conduct for doctors in Australia sets out the standards of ethical and professional conduct expected by the profession and the community; the current version took effect on 1 October 2020.2 The AMA’s Code of Ethics (2025 edition) sits alongside it as a statement of the profession’s ethical commitments.3 You do not need to quote either in Casper. What helps is knowing their themes, so your instincts match the profession’s: patient-centred care, honesty, respect, working within your competence, looking after colleagues and yourself, and acting when something is unsafe.

Table 3. Themes of Good medical practice and how they surface in Casper
Theme of the codeHow it surfaces in a scenario
Patient-centred, respectful careListening first; involving the person in decisions; respecting cultural and personal values
Honesty and open communicationDisclosing mistakes; not misleading; correcting a false impression
Working with colleaguesRespecting other professions; raising concerns privately and constructively
Minimising riskActing on a safety concern; knowing when to escalate
Professional behaviour and boundariesDeclining gifts or favours that create obligation; separating personal and professional roles
Doctors’ healthLooking after yourself and supporting a colleague who is struggling

Themes summarised by GP Institute from the code’s structure.2

3. Anatomy of a dilemma: the conflicts Casper is built on ★★★★

An ethical dilemma is not a choice between right and wrong. It is a choice between two things that both matter, where honouring one costs something on the other. Most Casper scenarios are built on a small number of recurring conflicts. Learning to recognise them in the first few seconds is the most valuable skill in this module, because the moment you can name the conflict, the shape of a good answer follows.

Table 4. Recurring value conflicts and what a thoughtful answer does with each
ConflictTypical scenarioWhat a thoughtful answer does
Autonomy and wellbeingA patient or friend chooses something riskyChecks understanding and capacity, explores reasons, respects the choice while keeping the door open
Honesty and kindnessFamily asks you to hide bad news; a friend wants reassurance you can’t honestly giveFinds a way to be truthful and compassionate at once; never lies
Loyalty and fairnessA friend or colleague asks you to bend a rule for themValues the relationship openly, explains why fairness to others matters, offers legitimate help
Individual and communityOne person’s request uses a shared, limited resourceConsiders who else is affected; applies transparent criteria
Rules and compassionA policy produces a harsh result for a vulnerable personRespects the reason for the rule, looks for discretion or a safe alternative, then fixes the policy
Hierarchy and conscienceA senior person instructs you to do something you think is wrongRaises the concern respectfully and privately; escalates if harm continues
Self-interest and dutyDoing the right thing costs you time, money or popularityAcknowledges the cost honestly and still chooses the duty
Response red flag: deciding in the first line

“Lying is wrong, so I would tell him the diagnosis” may end in a defensible place, but it skips everything a rater is looking for: what you would find out, who is affected, how you would do it kindly. Name the conflict first, then decide.

4. A five-step process for dilemmas ★★★★

Lesson 1 introduced five moves for any scenario. For explicitly ethical scenarios, the same moves apply with a sharper focus on values. Figure 1 is the version to practise until it is automatic.

1. Name the conflict“The tension here is between X and Y.” One sentence.
2. Find out what you don’t knowFacts, capacity, motives, risk. Who do I need to speak with, privately?
3. Consider every stakeholderHow each is affected; who is most vulnerable; what each would want
4. Choose and justifyThe option that best honours both values with the least harm; say why, and what would change your mind
5. Follow throughSupport people afterwards, document or escalate where needed, and prevent a repeat
Figure 1. Five steps for an ethical dilemma. GP Institute teaching framework. Casper point: step 4 must contain the word “because” (or its equivalent). A decision without reasons is half an answer.

4.1 Four quick tests for your decision ★★★★

Once you have a provisional decision, run it past four quick tests. You will not write them out, but they keep you away from answers that read badly.

Table 5. Four quick tests (GP Institute teaching tools)
TestQuestion to ask yourselfWhat a “fail” looks like
TransparencyWould I be comfortable if everyone involved knew exactly what I did and why?A plan that relies on someone not finding out
ConsistencyWould I make the same decision for a different person in the same situation?Favouring a friend, a senior colleague or a likeable patient
ProportionalityIs this the least drastic step that deals with the risk?Reporting to a regulator before speaking to the person; or doing nothing when harm is ongoing
PerspectiveHow would this look from the other person’s side?An answer that only makes sense from your own position

5. Prioritising when everything matters ★★★★

Many scenarios contain several problems at once: a distressed person, a policy breach, an angry senior, a deadline. Raters notice whether you deal with them in a sensible order. A useful ladder is to deal first with immediate risk to anyone’s safety, then with the most vulnerable person’s needs, then with honesty and fairness issues, then with relationships and feelings, and finally with systems and prevention. You can mention all of them; the order shows your judgement.

Swipe to see the whole figure →

Priority ladder: what to address first 1 Immediate safetyIs anyone at risk of harm right now? 2 The most vulnerable personWho has least power or most to lose? 3 Honesty and fairnessIs anyone being misled or treated unfairly? 4 Relationships and feelingsRepair trust; support the people involved 5 Systems and preventionWhat would stop this happening again?
Figure 2. A priority ladder for multi-issue scenarios. GP Institute teaching tool. Casper point: if your answer opens with a feelings issue while someone is at risk, raters will notice the order before the content.
Response pearl: one sentence of triage

When a scenario has several problems, start with a single sorting sentence: “My first concern is Mrs Lee’s safety; after that I’d deal with the conflict between the staff.” It shows the rater your judgement immediately and buys you a structure for the rest of the answer.

6. Showing a position without preaching ★★★★

Casper asks for your judgement, so you do need to reach a position. But the way you express it matters. Answers that moralise (“this behaviour is completely unacceptable and must be reported”) or sit on the fence (“there are many perspectives and it depends”) both score less well than answers that reach a reasoned, conditional position and show respect for the people involved.

Swipe to see the whole figure →

Where your answer should sit Moralising Absolute, judgemental, no reasons or conditions Reasoned, conditional position Clear decision, reasons, and what would change it; respectful to everyone involved Fence-sitting “It depends”, every view listed, no decision
Figure 3. Aim for the middle of the spectrum. GP Institute teaching tool. Casper point: raters can only judge a decision you actually make; they mark you down for a judgemental tone as well as for refusing to decide.
Table 6. Phrasing that helps and phrasing that hurts
Instead of…Try…Why it works better
“He is clearly in the wrong.”“I’d want to understand why he did this before deciding what to do.”Avoids assuming motives
“I would report her immediately.”“I’d speak to her privately first; if the risk continued, I’d escalate to…”Proportionate and staged
“It depends on the situation.”“If she understands the risks, I’d respect her choice; if I had doubts about her capacity, I’d…”Turns “it depends” into specific conditions
“Honesty is the best policy.”“I’d tell him the truth, gently and at his pace, because…”Replaces a slogan with action and reason
“I would never do that.”“I can see why it’s tempting, but I wouldn’t, because…”Shows empathy for the pressure and still holds the line
Build your experience bank

Recall a time when two of your own values pulled in different directions: perhaps loyalty to a friend and honesty, or a rule and compassion. Write down which values were in conflict, what you chose, and whether you would choose the same way now. “Describe a time when you faced an ethical dilemma” is one of the most common behavioural questions.

7. Integrity and self-reflection ★★★★

Ethical maturity includes knowing the limits of your own judgement. Strong answers often contain a line of self-awareness: acknowledging a bias (“I’d be careful not to let my friendship with him colour my view”), recognising when you need advice (“I’d talk it through with my supervisor or my medical defence organisation”), or admitting your own contribution to a problem. These lines are short, but they distinguish a reflective doctor from a confident rule-follower.

Integrity also means consistency between what you say and what you would do when it costs you. Scenarios often add a personal cost (losing a friend’s approval, upsetting a senior, working extra hours) to see whether your principles survive it. Acknowledge the cost honestly. “This would be uncomfortable, and I might lose some goodwill, but…” is more convincing than pretending the right choice is easy.

Build your experience bank

Think of a time you changed your mind about something important after hearing another person’s perspective. What did they say, and what did you do differently afterwards? This works for self-awareness, empathy and communication questions.

8. Worked scenarios

Try each scenario under the real time limit before you open the debrief. Your first instinct on the page is what you are training.

Scenario 1Typed · 3.5 minutes for both questions

EthicsCommunicationEmpathy

You are a GP registrar. Mr Wei Lau, 78, has just been found to have a cancer that is likely to be incurable; he has not yet been told. He speaks English well and lives independently. His daughter has phoned the practice and come in to talk with you and Dr Hollis, his long-standing GP and your supervisor. The practice nurse joins you afterwards.

Kim Lau (Mr Lau’s daughter): Please don’t tell Dad it’s cancer. In our family we protect our elders from news like this. He would give up.

Dr Margaret Hollis (practice principal and your supervisor): I’ve known this family for twenty years. Let’s respect their wishes for now and focus on keeping him comfortable.

Tom Bradley (practice nurse, recently graduated): He asked me straight out yesterday whether it was cancer. I said I didn’t know. What am I supposed to say next time?

  1. How would you respond to Tom’s question?
  2. How would you approach the conversation with Kim and Dr Hollis?
Your turn. Set a timer for 3.5 minutes and answer both questions before opening the debrief.
Open the debrief

What is really going on

The conflict is honesty and respect for Mr Lau’s autonomy against the family’s wish to protect him, which may be grounded in genuine cultural values about how bad news is shared. Mr Lau has capacity and has asked directly, which matters a great deal. Dr Hollis is your supervisor and knows the family well; Tom has been put in a position of saying something untrue. Unknowns: what Mr Lau himself wants to know and how he would like news shared, and whether he would want his daughter involved.

Perspectives to acknowledge

  • Mr Lau: entitled to information about his own health and to decide how much he wants to know.
  • Kim: loving and protective; may fear her father’s distress; may be expressing real family and cultural norms.
  • Dr Hollis: long relationship with the family, wants to avoid harm, but is your supervisor and accountable for the care.
  • Tom: uncomfortable, new, needs a clear and honest approach to follow.

A reasonable approach

  1. Support Tom: he shouldn’t have to give a false answer; agree he can say the doctors will talk with Mr Lau about his results very soon, and let you know if Mr Lau asks again.
  2. Acknowledge Kim’s love and the cultural importance of how news is shared; explain gently that you can’t lie to her father if he asks.
  3. Suggest a middle path: ask Mr Lau himself how much he wants to know and who he wants present. Some people prefer family to receive details; that is his choice to make.
  4. Raise this privately with Dr Hollis first, respectfully, as a shared plan rather than a challenge; agree who will lead the conversation.
  5. Plan a well-supported conversation and follow-up, with Kim present if Mr Lau wishes.
Weaker response pattern

“I’d tell Tom to keep saying he doesn’t know, because the family knows best and Dr Hollis is the senior doctor. It’s not my place to interfere.”

Accepts a falsehood, ignores Mr Lau’s autonomy and direct question, and defers entirely to hierarchy.

Stronger response pattern

“I’d tell Tom he doesn’t need to give a false answer; he can say we’ll discuss results with Mr Lau soon. With Kim and Dr Hollis I’d acknowledge how much she cares and that families share news differently, then suggest we ask Mr Lau how much he wants to know and who he’d like there, and plan the conversation together.”

Truthful and compassionate, respects culture and hierarchy, and puts the decision with the person who has the right to make it.

These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.

Check your own response. Did you…

Ticked: of 5

Missed several? Re-read section 3 →
Scenario 2Typed · 3.5 minutes for both questions

FairnessProblem-solvingEmpathy

Outside work, you volunteer each Saturday as the shift coordinator at a community food relief centre.

The centre has 40 food hampers this week and clear written criteria: households must have registered by Thursday, and hampers are given in order of registration. At closing time one hamper remains, already set aside for a registered family who have not yet arrived. A woman you have never met, Ana, arrives with two young children. She has not registered, says the family’s payment has been delayed and they have nothing for the weekend. Gary, a volunteer who has worked at the centre for fifteen years and is well respected, tells you quietly that the registered family “always turn up late and probably don’t need it as much”, and suggests you give the hamper to Ana. The registered family has not called to say they are coming.

  1. How would you respond to Ana and Gary in the next few minutes?
  2. What would you consider in deciding who receives the last hamper?
Your turn. Set a timer for 3.5 minutes and answer both questions before opening the debrief.
Open the debrief

What is really going on

This is a justice scenario: transparent rules protect fairness, but they can produce a harsh result for someone in genuine need. Gary’s suggestion is compassionate in intent but rests on an assumption about the registered family. Unknowns: whether the registered family is still coming, whether there are other resources (spare items, emergency vouchers, other services open this weekend), and Ana’s situation in more detail.

Perspectives to acknowledge

  • Ana and her children: urgent need, possibly embarrassed to ask.
  • The registered family: followed the process and are relying on it.
  • Gary: experienced, well-meaning, but making a judgement about another family.
  • The centre and community: trust depends on fair, consistent criteria.

A reasonable approach

  1. Greet Ana warmly and privately; acknowledge her situation without making promises yet.
  2. Try to contact the registered family before giving their hamper away.
  3. Look for other options: spare stock, emergency vouchers, a referral to another service open over the weekend; help Ana register for next week.
  4. Respond to Gary respectfully: thank him for caring, and explain why you can’t decide based on assumptions about another family.
  5. Afterwards, suggest the centre agree a small emergency reserve and a clear policy for unregistered urgent requests.
Weaker response pattern

“Rules are rules. Ana didn’t register, so I’d tell her to come back next week. I’d tell Gary not to judge other families.”

Applies the rule without exploring alternatives, leaves children without food over a weekend, and lectures a colleague.

Stronger response pattern

“I’d speak with Ana privately and kindly, then try to call the registered family. Meanwhile I’d look for spare items or a weekend emergency service and help her register. I’d thank Gary for caring but explain I can’t base it on assumptions about the other family. Later I’d suggest an emergency reserve policy.”

Compassionate and fair, gathers information, finds an alternative instead of a winner and loser, and fixes the system.

These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.

Check your own response. Did you…

Ticked: of 5

Missed several? Re-read section 5 →
Scenario 3Video · 1 minute per question

EthicsSelf-awarenessCommunication

You live in a small street where neighbours know you are a doctor. You are not anyone’s GP on the street.

Your neighbour, Mrs Patricia Doyle, knocks on your door one evening. Her son Liam, 24, has been refused a council parking permit near his workplace, and she is preparing an appeal. She asks you to write a short letter on your practice letterhead saying Liam has “a medical condition that makes walking long distances difficult”. You know Liam plays weekend football and you have never examined him. Mrs Doyle has been very kind to your family, including minding your children at short notice. She says “it’s just a formality, everyone does it”.

  1. How would you respond to Mrs Doyle’s request?
  2. Describe a time you had to say no to someone you cared about. How did you handle it?
Your turn. Record yourself on your phone: one minute for question 1, then one minute for question 2, without stopping in between. Use the box for notes if you like.
Open the debrief

What is really going on

The conflict is between gratitude and a relationship you value, and your integrity as a doctor. Writing a medical letter about someone you have not assessed, which you suspect is untrue, would be dishonest and could mislead a public authority. The pressure is social and emotional rather than hierarchical. There may also be a genuine need you are not aware of, so curiosity is better than accusation.

Perspectives to acknowledge

  • Mrs Doyle: wants to help her son, probably sees this as minor, values your friendship.
  • Liam: may have a real difficulty, or may simply want convenience; you don’t know.
  • The council and other residents: rely on medical letters being truthful.
  • You: your professional integrity and your relationship with a kind neighbour.

A reasonable approach

  1. Thank her for thinking of you and acknowledge how much her help has meant to your family.
  2. Explain kindly and clearly that you can’t write a medical letter about someone you haven’t assessed, and that it wouldn’t be honest.
  3. Stay curious: if Liam has a real difficulty, suggest he see his own GP, who can assess him and write a letter if appropriate.
  4. Keep the relationship warm; perhaps offer practical help another way.
Weaker response pattern

“I’d say no because that would be fraud and I could lose my registration. I’d tell her she shouldn’t ask doctors to lie.”

Correct conclusion but cold and accusatory; focuses on self-protection and damages the relationship.

Stronger response pattern

“I’d thank her, and say how much her help with the kids has meant to us. Then I’d explain I can’t write a medical letter for someone I haven’t examined, as it wouldn’t be honest. If Liam does struggle, his own GP can assess him properly. I’d make sure she knew I still valued her friendship.”

Kind and clear, explains the reason in terms of honesty, offers a legitimate path, and protects the relationship.

These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.

Check your own response. Did you…

Ticked: of 5

Missed several? Re-read section 6 →
Response-readiness check

Tick each item you could do in a real Casper sitting without looking back at this lesson.

Ready: of 8. Your ticks are not saved.

9. Key takeaways

Key takeaways
  • The nine RACGP competencies are judged through behaviour, not labels: show empathy, don’t announce it.
  • Older lists of 16+ competencies all map onto the nine; practise behaviours, not lists.
  • Autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice, plus honesty, confidentiality and professionalism, cover the values in most scenarios, clinical or not.
  • No principle is an automatic trump card; show the weighing.
  • Most scenarios are built on a handful of conflicts: autonomy and wellbeing, honesty and kindness, loyalty and fairness, individual and community, rules and compassion, hierarchy and conscience.
  • Name the conflict first, then gather information, consider stakeholders, decide with reasons, and follow through.
  • Test your decision: would it survive transparency, consistency, proportionality and the other person’s perspective?
  • When several issues compete, deal with safety and the most vulnerable person first.
  • Reach a conditional position (“if… I would…”) rather than moralising or saying “it depends”.
  • A line of self-awareness, such as a bias you would watch for or advice you would seek, marks a reflective answer.

Practice plan

WhenTask
TodayComplete the three worked scenarios under time; rewrite one weak answer using Table 6
Day 3For five practice scenarios, write only the one-sentence conflict statement; time yourself
Day 7Four typed and two video scenarios using the five dilemma steps
Day 14Add two “values in conflict” entries to your experience bank and rehearse them aloud
Week before your testMixed timed set including at least two non-clinical dilemmas

Your next step

Choose the line that matches your self-ratings and scenario self-checks in this lesson.

Two or more “Not yet” ratings, or under half ticked on most scenario self-checks: go back to the core approach before moving on.Re-read section 4
Most self-checks more than half ticked: you have the approach; build speed with more timed scenarios on this theme.Practise more scenarios
Every self-check fully or almost fully ticked and readiness all ticked: move on to lesson 3 (confidentiality, conflicts of interest and boundaries).Sit a timed mock

References

  1. Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. National entry assessment. https://www.racgp.org.au/a-career-in-general-practice/become-a-gp/national-entry-assessment (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
  2. Medical Board of Australia. Good medical practice: a code of conduct for doctors in Australia (effective 1 October 2020). https://www.medicalboard.gov.au/Codes-Guidelines-Policies/Code-of-conduct (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
  3. Australian Medical Association. AMA Code of Ethics 2025. https://www.ama.com.au/sites/default/files/2026-02/AMA_Code_of_Ethics_2025.pdf (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
  4. Beauchamp TL, Childress JF. Principles of biomedical ethics. 8th ed. New York: Oxford University Press; 2019.

Recommended reading

  • Medical Board of Australia, Good medical practice: read sections on patient-centred care, honesty and working with colleagues.2
  • AMA Code of Ethics 2025: a short read on the profession’s ethical commitments.3
  • Beauchamp and Childress, Principles of biomedical ethics: chapters on the four principles.4
Casper is a registered trademark of Acuity Insights. GP Institute of Australia is independent and is not affiliated with, endorsed by or connected to Acuity Insights, the RACGP or ACRRM. Scenarios in this lesson are original and fictional; any resemblance to real people or events is coincidental. This lesson is educational and is not legal advice; laws differ between states and territories.

Version history

VersionDateChanges
1.017 Nov 2026First release: merged and rewritten from source lessons 1.3 Key competencies; 2.1 Core principles of medical ethics; 2.4 Ethical dilemmas in general practice
© 2026 GP Institute of Australia. For personal study only. Not to be reproduced without permission.

The Australian General Practice Training (AGPT) Situational Judgement Test (SJT) is a key component of the GP selection process. Designed to assess candidates’ judgement in practical, real-world situations, the SJT evaluates non-clinical skills critical to effective general practice. Understanding the format and structure of the AGPT SJT is essential for success, as it allows candidates to approach the test with confidence and strategic focus.

Casper-Style SJT in AGPT Selection

In addition to the traditional SJT format, the AGPT selection process now incorporates the Casper-style SJT, which consists of 11 scenarios: four video response scenarios and seven typed response scenarios. This adaptation further evaluates candidates’ ability to articulate their reasoning and decision-making process in real-time.

Exam Format and Structure

The Casper-style SJT includes two main question types:

  1. Video Response Scenarios: In video response scenarios, candidates must verbally explain their approach to a given situation within a limited timeframe. 4 scenarios and 8 questions to be answered in 8 minutes, with 1 minute for each question.
  2. Typed Response Scenarios: Typed response scenarios require candidates to provide written explanations of their reasoning and decision-making process. These formats test communication skills, clarity of thought, and the ability to respond under pressure. Here 7 scenarios as given with 2 questions per scenario, and 3.5 minutes to answer 2 questions.

Each scenario is crafted to reflect challenges faced by General Practitioners, such as managing time-sensitive patient concerns, addressing ethical dilemmas, or navigating conflicts within a healthcare team. The test is typically completed within 90 minutes, emphasizing the importance of time management and clear, concise reasoning.

Key Competencies Assessed

The AGPT SJT, including the Casper-style format, evaluates a range of non-technical skills essential for effective general practice:

  1. Professionalism: Demonstrating integrity, accountability, and adherence to ethical standards.
  2. Communication Skills: Conveying empathy, clarity, and understanding in patient and team interactions.
  3. Teamwork: Collaborating effectively with colleagues and resolving conflicts constructively.
  4. Resilience and Adaptability: Managing stress and responding to unexpected challenges with composure.
  5. Patient-Centered Care: Balancing clinical decisions with patient preferences and safety.

Preparation Strategies for Success

Preparation for the AGPT SJT involves practicing with and focusing on:

  1. Familiarizing themselves with the Casper-style format, including video and typed responses.
  2. Practicing articulating their reasoning clearly and concisely within time constraints.
  3. Prioritizing patient safety and ethical considerations in every scenario.
  4. Answering professionally as a GP, avoiding personal biases.
  5. Using a systematic approach to evaluate options, ensuring decisions align with RACGP standards.

The SJT is not just an exam; it’s a reflection of your readiness to handle the complexities of General Practice. By understanding the purpose of the test, familiarizing yourself with its format, and focusing on key competencies, you can approach the AGPT selection process with confidence. Practicing sample scenarios and refining your communication skills will enhance your ability to demonstrate professionalism, empathy, and sound judgement-qualities essential for a successful career as a General Practitioner.

Scroll to Top