GP Institute of Australia · AGPT selection: the Casper SJT · Lesson 11 of 16
Professionalism in practice: social media, records and medico-legal situations
Keep your professional obligations online and on paper, write records you would be glad to have read aloud, and respond to complaints and legal requests calmly, honestly and with the right advice.
The RACGP national entry assessment is Acuity Insights’ Casper test: 11 scenarios with two open-ended questions each, four answered on video (one minute per question) and seven typed (3.5 minutes for both questions). It assesses nine competencies, not clinical knowledge, so this lesson teaches judgement and communication rather than clinical facts.1
Where are you starting from?
Rate yourself honestly. There are no marks here; each “Not yet” or “Somewhat” points you to the part of this lesson that closes that gap.
I know which professional obligations apply to my social media use, including personal accounts.
I can describe what makes a medical record accurate, objective and defensible.
I know never to alter a record after the event, and what to do instead.
I know the first steps when I receive a complaint, subpoena or request from police or a coroner.
I can say no to a request to falsify a document, billing or certificate.
“Not yet” answers: . Your choices are not saved.
Learning objectives
- Apply professional obligations to social media, including personal use.
- Write accurate, objective, contemporaneous records and correct them properly.
- Respond to complaints and legal requests with honesty and early advice.
- Recognise and refuse requests to falsify records, certificates or billing.
- Explain why professionalism outside the consulting room protects public trust.
How this shows up in Casper
- Scenario types: a colleague’s social media post; a request to ‘tidy up’ notes after a complaint; a certificate or billing request that isn’t honest; a legal request for records.
- Typical question stems: “How would you respond to…?”, “How would you prepare for…?”, “How should doctors balance…?”
- Common trap: panicking and covering up, or being so defensive that honesty and the patient’s interests get lost.
| ★★★★ | Must master: shapes almost every answer on this theme |
| ★★★★ | High yield: frequent scenario types and common traps |
| ★★★★ | Know the principles: background that sharpens your judgement |
| ★★★★ | Background: context |
Ratings are GP Institute’s editorial judgement, not an official RACGP or Acuity Insights weighting. Any competency can appear in any scenario.
1. Professionalism beyond the consulting room ★★★★
Doctors are trusted partly because the community believes their professional standards do not switch off when they leave work. The Medical Board of Australia’s code, Good medical practice, describes the professional behaviour expected of doctors, including honesty, respect and maintaining public trust in the profession.2 In Casper, professionalism scenarios often sit in grey areas: a joke online, a request from a senior to “fix” something, a legal letter that triggers panic. Raters look for integrity that holds under pressure, and for calm, proportionate action.
| Setting | What is at stake | Typical Casper tension |
|---|---|---|
| Social media | Confidentiality, public trust, advertising rules | Self-expression and humour against professional image |
| Medical records | Continuity of care, honesty, legal defensibility | Pressure to change notes after something goes wrong |
| Complaints and legal processes | Fairness, honesty, the patient’s ongoing care | Self-protection against openness |
| Certificates, reports and billing | Truthfulness to third parties and the public purse | Helping a patient or a practice against honesty |
2. Social media ★★★★
Ahpra and the National Boards publish guidance on how registered practitioners can meet their obligations on social media. It does not create new rules; it explains that the obligations you already have apply online too: confidentiality and privacy, your Board’s code of conduct, and the rules on advertising health services.3 Those obligations follow you onto personal accounts as well as professional ones, because people can connect your posts to your profession even without your title.
| Lower risk | Higher risk |
|---|---|
| Sharing reputable public health information | Posting claims that contradict accepted evidence or public health advice |
| General reflections on work with nothing identifiable | Case stories with details that could identify a patient, especially in small communities |
| Private, respectful personal content | Abusive, discriminatory or harassing posts, even on a personal account |
| Declining patients’ friend requests politely | Accepting patients as personal contacts and discussing their care online |
| Practice pages that follow advertising rules | Using patient testimonials to advertise a health service |
| Thinking before replying to a negative review | Replying to reviews with clinical details (lesson 6) |
GP Institute summary; read Ahpra’s guidance for the detail.3
When a colleague posts something unwise, a private message is almost always the right first step: kind, specific and quick, so they can take it down before harm spreads. Public call-outs humiliate and rarely help the patient.
3. Medical records and documentation ★★★★
Good records protect patients first: they let the next clinician understand what happened, what was decided and why. Good medical practice expects doctors to keep accurate, up-to-date and legible records that report relevant details of clinical history, findings, decisions and information given to patients.2 Patients generally have a right to access information held about them, under the Privacy Act’s Australian Privacy Principles and some state laws, so write every note as though the patient may read it.4
| Feature | What it means | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Contemporaneous | Written at the time or as soon as possible afterwards | Notes completed before the next patient |
| Accurate and complete | History, findings, reasoning, plan, advice given, safety-netting | “Advised to return if fever persists beyond 48 hours.” |
| Objective and respectful | Facts and quotes, not judgements | “Patient raised voice and said…” rather than “aggressive, difficult patient” |
| Attributable | Clear who wrote it and when | Electronic login, never someone else’s |
| Correctly amended | Later additions dated and marked as additions; original kept | “Addendum (date): on review of…” |
Altering, backdating or deleting a record after a complaint or an adverse outcome is a serious breach of honesty, even when the change seems to make the record “more accurate”. A later clarification is acceptable only as a clearly dated addendum, with the original left intact.
Swipe to see the whole figure →
4. Complaints and legal processes ★★★★
Most doctors will receive a complaint at some point, and some will receive a subpoena, a coroner’s request or a police request for information. These are stressful, and stress pushes people towards defensiveness or concealment. The professional response is steady: keep caring for the patient, be honest, don’t alter anything, and get advice early from your medical defence organisation. Good medical practice expects doctors to respond to complaints promptly and constructively and not to let them affect the patient’s care.2
| Situation | First steps | Avoid |
|---|---|---|
| A patient complains directly | Listen, acknowledge, apologise for their experience, look into it, respond (lesson 6) | Defensiveness; withdrawing care |
| Complaint to a health complaints body or Ahpra | Contact your defence organisation; tell your supervisor; respond factually within deadlines | Contacting the patient to pressure them; altering notes |
| Subpoena or court order for records | Check validity and scope with advice; provide only what is required | Ignoring it, or sending the whole file unchecked |
| Request from a coroner | Seek advice; provide a factual report based on the records | Speculation beyond what you know |
| Police request without a warrant | Check consent or legal basis; seek advice (lesson 3) | Refusing rudely or handing over records without a basis |
| Insurance or employer report | Only with informed, specific consent; factual and within your expertise | Advocacy that misrepresents facts |
Teaching summary, not legal advice. Processes differ between states and territories.
Think of a time you were criticised or complained about, at work or elsewhere. What was your first reaction, what did you actually do, and what would you do now? Keep the focus on your response and learning, not on proving you were right.
5. Integrity under pressure: certificates, reports and billing ★★★★
Doctors write documents that others rely on: medical certificates, insurance reports, workers’ compensation forms, letters for housing or immigration, and claims to Medicare. Each is a statement of truth to a third party. Pressure to bend them comes from sympathetic patients, family, friends and sometimes from practices. Lesson 2’s neighbour scenario is an example. The professional answer is to be helpful within the truth.
| Request | Honest alternative |
|---|---|
| Backdate a medical certificate | Certify only what you can; some certificates can describe what the patient reports about earlier days, clearly worded |
| “Add a diagnosis so the claim is approved” | Write what you assessed; suggest other legitimate supports |
| Bill a longer consultation than occurred | Bill what was provided; raise practice pressure through proper channels |
| Sign a form for a patient you haven’t assessed | Book a proper assessment first |
| Use a colleague’s login or signature | Never; fix the workflow (lesson 9) |
Pair every refusal with a legitimate way to help: a proper assessment, a truthful letter, a referral, or advice on other supports. It shows that integrity and compassion are not opposites.
Recall a time someone asked you to bend a rule or the truth for them. How did you say no while still helping, and how did they react?
6. Worked scenarios
Try each scenario under the real time limit before you open the debrief. Your first instinct on the page is what you are training.
EthicsCommunicationSelf-awareness
You are a GP registrar. A patient has lodged a complaint with the state health complaints body about a delayed referral by your supervisor, Dr Grant. The practice has been asked for the records.
Dr Martin Grant (practice principal and your supervisor): Before we send the notes, can you go into my entry from March and add that I advised him to come back if it got worse? I definitely said it. Just put it in that day’s note.
Leanne Fox (practice manager): We need to send the records by Friday. I don’t want this to drag on.
Sophie Nguyen (practice nurse): I was in the room that day. I’m not sure what was said about coming back.
- How would you respond to Dr Grant’s request?
- How would you suggest the practice handles the complaint?
Open the debrief
What is really going on
A senior colleague, under stress, is asking you to alter a record retrospectively in a way that would mislead the complaints body. Even if he did give the advice, inserting it into the original entry is dishonest. There is a power imbalance (he is your supervisor), a deadline, and a nurse unsure of the facts.
Perspectives to acknowledge
- The patient: entitled to a fair, honest process and continued care.
- Dr Grant: anxious, believes he gave the advice, probably not thinking clearly.
- Leanne: wants the process handled efficiently.
- Sophie: unsure, and should not be pressured.
- You: your integrity, your training relationship.
A reasonable approach
- Decline respectfully and clearly: you can’t change the original entry.
- Acknowledge how stressful a complaint is and that he may well have given the advice.
- Explain the honest option: if he recalls it, he can write a clearly dated addendum or include it in his response, stating it is his recollection.
- Suggest calling the medical defence organisation before sending anything.
- Send the records as they are, on time, with advice; keep caring for the patient; avoid pressuring Sophie.
“He’s my supervisor and he says he gave the advice, so I’d add it to the March note. It’s only making the record complete.”
Falsifies a record under pressure; serious dishonesty regardless of intent.
“I’d say gently that I can’t edit the March note, as that would look like changing records after a complaint. I can see this is stressful and he may well have said it; he can write a dated addendum or explain it in his response. I’d suggest we call the defence organisation today, then send the records unchanged by Friday.”
Honest, respectful to a senior, offers the legitimate route, and seeks advice.
These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.
Ticked: of 5
FairnessEthicsCommunication
Outside work, you volunteer as the social media coordinator for a community choir of about 60 members.
On Saturday a long-standing member, Trevor, posts a rehearsal photo on the choir’s public Facebook page. It includes a 12-year-old member, Mia, whose parents ticked “no photos online” on her enrolment form. Under the photo, several members have started commenting about the choir’s former conductor, who left on bad terms, calling her “useless” and “a fraud”. The post has 40 likes and is being shared. Trevor is well liked and has been with the choir for 20 years. The choir has no written social media policy.
- How would you respond to the post right now?
- How would you help the choir prevent this happening again?
Open the debrief
What is really going on
Two problems: a child’s photo published against her parents’ wishes (privacy and safety), and comments that could be defamatory and hurtful to a former conductor. Speed matters because the post is spreading. Trevor probably meant well. The lack of a policy is a system gap.
Perspectives to acknowledge
- Mia and her parents: consent ignored; possible safety concerns.
- The former conductor: being publicly disparaged.
- Trevor: likely unaware of the consent form.
- The choir: reputation and members’ trust.
A reasonable approach
- Act immediately on the child’s photo: hide or remove the post (or the photo) using your admin access.
- Hide or remove the disparaging comments.
- Message Trevor privately and kindly to explain why.
- Contact Mia’s parents, apologise, and tell them what you did.
- Afterwards, propose a simple social media policy: photo consent checks, respectful comments, admin moderation, and a contact for concerns.
“I’d leave it up because Trevor’s been in the choir for 20 years and people are enjoying it, but I’d ask people to be nicer in the comments.”
Leaves a child’s photo up against her parents’ wishes and tolerates harmful comments.
“I’d take the post down straight away, since Mia’s parents said no photos, and hide the comments about the old conductor. I’d message Trevor privately so he doesn’t feel embarrassed, and call Mia’s parents to apologise and explain. Then I’d suggest a short policy: check photo consent, keep comments respectful, and moderate the page.”
Fast and proportionate, protects the child first, kind to Trevor, honest with parents, and fixes the system.
These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.
Ticked: of 5
CommunicationEthicsSelf-awareness
You are a GP registrar. A fellow registrar, Dr Sam Rivera, has become popular on a video-sharing app with funny short videos about life as a junior doctor.
Sam’s videos are mostly harmless, but several are filmed in your practice, and in one a patient’s face is visible in the background of the waiting room and a computer screen with a patient list can be seen. Sam asks you to appear in a new video this week, filmed during a lunch break in the treatment room. He says it is great for the practice’s profile and the practice manager loves the extra new patients. The practice has no social media policy.
- How would you respond to Sam’s invitation?
- How do you think doctors can balance self-expression and professionalism online?
Open the debrief
What is really going on
Professional self-expression online is not wrong, but the existing videos have already exposed identifiable patient information. The invitation is a chance to address that kindly. The practice manager’s enthusiasm adds pressure, and there is no policy.
Perspectives to acknowledge
- Patients: privacy breached without consent.
- Sam: enjoys it, probably hasn’t noticed the risks.
- The practice: benefits commercially but carries the privacy risk.
- You: collegiality and your own professional image.
A reasonable approach
- Thank Sam and respond with warmth; you’re not against the videos in principle.
- Point out privately the patient visible in the background and the screen, and suggest removing those videos promptly.
- Suggest filming only where no patients or records could appear, and checking against Ahpra’s social media guidance.
- Decline to appear in the treatment room, or agree only to something clearly safe.
- Suggest the practice develops a social media policy.
“It sounds fun and the practice manager approves, so I’d join in and make sure I don’t say anything about patients.”
Misses the existing privacy breach and the risk of filming in clinical areas.
“I’d say I enjoy his videos, but I noticed a patient’s face and a screen with patient names in one of them, and suggest he takes those down. I’d pass on filming in the treatment room, but happily help with something clearly safe. More broadly, I think doctors can be themselves online as long as patients can’t be identified and the content keeps trust in the profession.”
Collegial and specific, addresses the real breach, offers a safe alternative, and gives a balanced view.
These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.
Ticked: of 5
Tick each item you could do in a real Casper sitting without looking back at this lesson.
- Not yet? Re-read section 2 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 2 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 3 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 3 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 4 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 5 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 2 →
Ready: of 7. Your ticks are not saved.
7. Key takeaways
- Professional obligations do not switch off outside the consulting room.
- Ahpra’s social media guidance applies your existing obligations online: confidentiality, the code of conduct and advertising rules.
- Personal accounts count: people can link posts to your profession.
- Pause before posting: identifiable? comfortable if the Board read it? accurate and respectful?
- Correct a colleague’s online mistake privately and quickly.
- Good records are contemporaneous, accurate, objective, attributable and correctly amended.
- Never alter, backdate or delete a record after the event; add a dated addendum.
- With complaints and legal requests: pause, get medical defence advice early, keep caring for the patient, respond honestly and on time.
- Certificates, reports and bills are statements of truth to third parties.
- Be helpful within the truth: pair every refusal with a legitimate way to help.
Practice plan
| When | Task |
|---|---|
| Today | Complete the three worked scenarios under time |
| Day 3 | Review your own social media against the ‘pause before posting’ checks |
| Day 7 | Four typed and two video scenarios on records, complaints and integrity |
| Day 14 | Add a ‘bent the rules’ or ‘criticism’ entry to your experience bank |
| Week before your test | Mixed timed set; check every integrity answer includes a legitimate alternative |
Your next step
Choose the line that matches your self-ratings and scenario self-checks in this lesson.
References
- Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. National entry assessment. https://www.racgp.org.au/a-career-in-general-practice/become-a-gp/national-entry-assessment (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Medical Board of Australia. Good medical practice: a code of conduct for doctors in Australia (effective 1 October 2020). https://www.medicalboard.gov.au/Codes-Guidelines-Policies/Code-of-conduct (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency. Social media: how to meet your obligations under the National Law. https://www.ahpra.gov.au/Resources/Social-media-guidance.aspx (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Office of the Australian Information Commissioner. Guide to health privacy, chapter 4: Giving access to health information. https://www.oaic.gov.au/privacy/privacy-guidance-for-organisations-and-government-agencies/health-service-providers/guide-to-health-privacy/chapter-4-giving-access-to-health-information (accessed 17 Nov 2026).