GP Institute of Australia · AGPT selection: the Casper SJT · Lesson 10 of 10
Mental health, substance use and vulnerable people: judgement without judgementalism
Respond to distress, risk and substance use with respect and courage: ask directly, connect people with help, balance confidentiality with safety, and challenge stigma, in clinics and in everyday life.
The RACGP national entry assessment is Acuity Insights’ Casper test: 11 scenarios with two open-ended questions each, four answered on video (one minute per question) and seven typed (3.5 minutes for both questions). It assesses nine competencies, not clinical knowledge, so this lesson teaches judgement and communication rather than clinical facts.1
Where are you starting from?
Rate yourself honestly. There are no marks here; each “Not yet” or “Somewhat” points you to the part of this lesson that closes that gap.
I use respectful, non-stigmatising language about mental illness and substance use.
I know how to approach a friend or colleague I’m worried about.
I would ask someone directly about suicidal thoughts if I were concerned.
I can explain the ‘least restrictive’ principle in mental health care.
I can talk with someone about substance use without judgement.
I know how to balance a young adult’s confidentiality with their safety and their family’s concerns.
“Not yet” answers: . Your choices are not saved.
Learning objectives
- Use respectful language and challenge stigma about mental illness and substance use.
- Notice distress, ask, listen and connect people with help, inside and outside clinical settings.
- Respond to possible suicide risk with direct, compassionate questions and appropriate urgency.
- Explain the principles behind mental health law, including the least restrictive approach.
- Apply harm-minimisation and non-judgemental approaches to substance use, and balance confidentiality, safety and family involvement.
How this shows up in Casper
- Scenario types: a friend or colleague who seems not to be coping; a patient who discloses suicidal thoughts and asks you not to tell family; stigma in a team; a housemate’s drinking.
- Typical question stems: “How would you approach…?”, “How would you respond to his request?”, “How would you help reduce stigma…?”
- Common trap: either avoiding the hard question or jumping to the most coercive option.
| ★★★★ | Must master: shapes almost every answer on this theme |
| ★★★★ | High yield: frequent scenario types and common traps |
| ★★★★ | Know the principles: background that sharpens your judgement |
| ★★★★ | Background: context |
Ratings are GP Institute’s editorial judgement, not an official RACGP or Acuity Insights weighting. Any competency can appear in any scenario.
This lesson discusses suicide and substance use. If it raises anything for you, please talk to someone you trust, your GP, or call Lifeline on 13 11 14. In an emergency, call 000.5
1. Stigma and the language we use ★★★★
Casper does not test psychiatry. But mental health and substance use appear often in scenarios, both clinical and everyday, because they test empathy, fairness and ethics under pressure. The first thing raters notice is attitude: whether you see the person or the label. Stigma is one of the biggest barriers to people seeking help, and health professionals can reinforce it without meaning to.
Mindframe, Australia’s national program on safe communication about suicide, mental ill-health and alcohol and other drugs, recommends language that is accurate, person-centred and avoids sensationalising or blaming.3
| Avoid | Prefer | Why |
|---|---|---|
| “Committed suicide” | “Died by suicide” | “Committed” implies a crime or sin |
| “An addict”, “a junkie” | “A person who uses drugs”; “a person with a substance use disorder” | The person comes before the condition |
| “A schizophrenic” | “A person living with schizophrenia” | Illness is not identity |
| “Drug seeker” | “A person requesting medication”; describe the behaviour | Labels close down curiosity about pain or dependence |
| “Attention-seeking” | “Distressed”; “asking for help” | Behaviour that seeks attention often signals need |
In any scenario involving mental illness or drug use, your first sentence should be about the person’s wellbeing or experience, not their diagnosis or behaviour: “I’d be worried about how Lachlan is coping since losing his job.”
2. Noticing distress in everyday life ★★★★
Many Casper scenarios are set outside medicine: a team-mate withdrawing, a friend’s worrying message, a colleague who seems exhausted. You are not expected to diagnose; you are expected to notice, care and act sensibly. A simple sequence works in almost every case.
Think of a time you noticed someone was struggling and reached out, or a time you wish you had. What did you say, how did they respond, and what did you learn? Avoid details that would identify the person.
3. Responding when someone may be at risk ★★★★
When you are worried someone may be thinking about suicide, the most important step is to ask directly and compassionately. Asking about suicide does not put the idea in someone’s head; it gives them permission to talk. Then listen, take what they say seriously, and help them connect with support. If there is immediate danger, the priority is safety: stay with them or make sure someone does, and call 000.5 As a GP you will have formal assessment and safety-planning skills; in Casper, what matters is the compassion, the directness and the judgement about urgency.
“I promise I won’t tell anyone” is a promise you may not be able to keep. Strong answers say they will respect privacy as far as possible, but will need to involve others if someone’s life is at risk, and they say that honestly to the person.
4. Mental health law: the principles ★★★★
Each Australian state and territory has its own mental health legislation. The details differ, but the principles are broadly shared: people with mental illness have the same rights as anyone else; treatment should be voluntary wherever possible; involuntary assessment or treatment is a last resort for serious risk when less restrictive options are not enough; and care should be the least restrictive option that is safe, with the person involved in decisions as much as possible. Casper will not ask you about sections of an Act. It may test whether you instinctively choose the least coercive option that keeps people safe.
| Principle | What it means in a scenario |
|---|---|
| Least restrictive care | Choose the option with the least restriction of freedom that still manages the risk |
| Voluntary first | Try to engage the person in agreeing to help before considering compulsion |
| Capacity and participation | Involve the person in decisions; respect their views; support decision-making |
| Rights and dignity | Explain what is happening and why; inform them of their rights |
| Involving carers | Recognise families and carers as partners, while respecting the person’s privacy |
| Safety | Act when there is serious risk to the person or others |
Teaching summary of common principles; check your state or territory’s Act for specifics.
5. Substance use without judgement ★★★★
Australia’s National Drug Strategy is built on harm minimisation, which combines demand reduction, supply reduction and harm reduction.4 For a GP, and in Casper, this means meeting people where they are: reducing harm even when someone is not ready to stop, without moralising. Change is usually gradual, and people move back and forth between stages of readiness.
Swipe to see the whole figure →
| Judgemental | Supportive |
|---|---|
| “You need to stop drinking.” | “How do you feel about your drinking at the moment?” |
| Refusing care until they stop | Continuing care and reducing harm in the meantime |
| Assuming every request for medication is “seeking” | Exploring pain, dependence and needs, with consistent, safe limits |
| Treating a setback as failure | Treating a setback as part of the process |
Non-judgemental doesn’t mean ignoring danger. If someone’s substance use puts others at immediate risk (for example, drink-driving or caring for young children while intoxicated), say clearly that you would act, and how.
6. Confidentiality, safety and families ★★★★
Young adults and their families often want different things. An adult patient is entitled to confidentiality, including from parents (lesson 3). Families are often the most important support and may hold vital information. Good care listens to families without disclosing what the patient hasn’t agreed to share, encourages the patient to involve their supports, and shares information without consent only when necessary to prevent a serious threat to life, health or safety.2
| You can always… | With consent you can… | Without consent, only if… |
|---|---|---|
| Listen to family concerns and information | Share relevant information and the plan | Necessary to prevent a serious threat to life, health or safety |
| Give general information about services and support | Invite them into a consultation | Required by law |
| Acknowledge their worry | Agree a shared safety plan | With senior advice, documented, minimal |
Recall a time you had to keep something confidential while someone else wanted to know: perhaps a friend’s secret, or a patient’s information. How did you handle the person asking, and how did you decide what you could say?
7. Looking after yourself ★★★★
| Who needs support | Options |
|---|---|
| A person in immediate danger | 000; stay with them |
| A person in crisis, not in immediate danger | Lifeline 13 11 14; their GP; local mental health services |
| A friend or family member worried about someone | Their own GP; carer support services; crisis lines for advice |
| A doctor or colleague | Their own GP; doctors’ health advisory services; employee assistance programs |
| You, after a confronting situation | Debrief with your supervisor; your own GP; doctors’ health services |
Supporting people in distress is emotionally demanding. Debriefing, supervision, having your own GP and using doctors’ health services are part of professional practice, not optional extras. In a Casper answer, a single closing line about debriefing after a confronting situation shows self-awareness and resilience.
8. Worked scenarios
Try each scenario under the real time limit before you open the debrief. Your first instinct on the page is what you are training.
EthicsEmpathyCommunication
You are a GP registrar. Josh Taylor, 19, has seen you twice for low mood. Today he tells you that he has had thoughts of ending his life in the past fortnight, though he says he has no plan and wouldn’t act on them because of his younger sister. His mother is in the waiting room.
Josh Taylor (patient, aged 19): Please don’t tell Mum anything. She’ll freak out and it’ll make everything worse.
Karen Taylor (Josh’s mother, who catches you in the corridor): I’m his mother. I know something’s wrong. I have a right to know what’s going on with my son.
Dr Patricia Lowe (your supervisor, when you discuss it with her): If he’s had thoughts of suicide, we tell the family. Simple.
- How would you respond to Josh’s request?
- How would you respond to Karen and to Dr Lowe?
Open the debrief
What is really going on
An adult patient has disclosed suicidal thoughts, without a plan and with a protective factor, and asks for confidentiality. His mother is worried and wants information. Your supervisor proposes automatic disclosure. The task is to take the risk seriously, work out how immediate it is, keep Josh engaged, and involve support in a way he can agree to, sharing without consent only if there is a serious threat.
Perspectives to acknowledge
- Josh: vulnerable, has trusted you, fears his mother’s reaction.
- Karen: frightened and loving; possibly an important support.
- Dr Lowe: rightly concerned about safety; proposing a blanket rule.
- You: balancing trust, safety and supervision.
A reasonable approach
- Thank Josh for telling you; take it seriously; explore further and work out how urgent the risk is (with your supervisor).
- Be honest with him: you’ll respect his privacy, but if you were worried his life was in danger you’d need to involve others.
- Explore what he’d be comfortable with: perhaps telling his mum something general, or having you present while he tells her; agree a safety and support plan and follow-up.
- With Karen: acknowledge her worry, listen to what she has noticed, give general information about support without disclosing, and encourage her to talk with Josh.
- With Dr Lowe: share your assessment and suggest that disclosure without consent depends on the level of risk; agree the plan together and document it.
“I’d tell Josh I have to inform his mother because he’s had suicidal thoughts, and then explain everything to Karen.”
Breaks trust automatically without assessing risk or seeking consent; may stop Josh seeking help.
“I’d thank Josh for trusting me, take it seriously and assess how safe he is with Dr Lowe. I’d be honest that I’d respect his privacy unless I thought his life was in danger. I’d ask whether he’d let me help him tell his mum something, and agree a support plan and a review soon. I’d listen to Karen and acknowledge her worry without sharing details, and talk the threshold for disclosure through with Dr Lowe.”
Takes risk seriously, honest about limits, seeks consent, supports the family, and engages the supervisor.
These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.
Ticked: of 5
EmpathyEthicsCommunication
Outside work, you share a house with your friend Lachlan, 28.
Since losing his job three months ago, Lachlan has been drinking most nights, sleeping until midday and has stopped going to football. Last Saturday you saw him drive home from the pub after what you know was at least five or six drinks. When you mentioned it the next morning he laughed it off, said he was “fine to drive”, and asked you not to say anything to his parents, who live interstate and “already think I’m a failure”. He is planning to drive to a friend’s party this weekend.
- How would you approach Lachlan about his drinking and mood?
- What would you do about the risk of drink-driving this weekend?
Open the debrief
What is really going on
Two related issues: a friend who may be depressed and using alcohol to cope after a major loss, and an immediate risk to him and others from drink-driving. The first needs patience and support; the second needs a clear, firm boundary.
Perspectives to acknowledge
- Lachlan: loss, shame, low mood; may not see the drinking as a problem.
- Other road users: at risk from drink-driving.
- His parents: may be an important support, but he has asked for privacy.
- You: friend and housemate; not his doctor.
A reasonable approach
- Choose a calm, sober moment; say what you’ve noticed and that you’re worried, without labelling him.
- Ask how he’s really going since losing his job; listen; ask directly about hopeless thoughts if it seems right.
- Encourage him to see a GP and offer to help him book; mention support lines.
- On drink-driving: be clear and non-negotiable; offer practical alternatives such as a lift, a taxi or staying over; if he still intends to drive intoxicated, you would take the keys or call the police to prevent harm.
- Respect his wish about his parents unless his safety becomes at risk; keep checking in.
“It’s his life and I’m not his doctor, so I’d stay out of it, but I’d tell him drink-driving is illegal.”
Avoids the conversation about his wellbeing and offers no real plan for an immediate danger.
“I’d pick a quiet morning and say I’ve noticed he’s been having a rough time since the job, and ask how he’s really going. I’d suggest seeing a GP and offer to help book it. On the driving I’d be clear: I’m not okay with him driving after drinking, and I’ll drive him or get him an Uber. If he still tried to drive drunk, I’d take the keys or call the police.”
Caring and specific about wellbeing, firm and practical about immediate danger, and clear about escalation.
These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.
Ticked: of 5
FairnessEmpathyCommunication
You are a GP registrar at a team meeting in a suburban practice.
One of the GPs, Dr Colin Webb, suggests the practice stop accepting new patients on opioid treatment programs because they are “trouble”, “scare the other patients” and “take up too much time”. Two staff members nod. A receptionist mentions that last month one patient on the program shouted at the front desk. The practice currently cares for eight patients on the program, most of whom have been stable for years.
- How would you respond to Dr Webb’s suggestion?
- How would you help reduce stigma toward patients who use drugs in the practice?
Open the debrief
What is really going on
A proposal that would exclude a whole group of patients based on stereotypes, generalised from one incident. It would reduce access to evidence-based treatment for a vulnerable group. The concerns behind it (staff safety, workload) are real and deserve solutions that don’t discriminate.
Perspectives to acknowledge
- Patients on the program: mostly stable; facing stigma; few alternatives.
- Staff: one frightening incident; need to feel safe.
- Dr Webb: concerned about time and safety, but generalising.
- The practice: responsibilities to fairness and community health.
A reasonable approach
- Acknowledge the incident and the staff’s need to feel safe, and the workload concern.
- Respectfully point out that most of the current patients are stable, and that excluding a group based on one incident would be unfair and harm people’s access to treatment.
- Suggest addressing specific behaviour with the practice’s usual policy for anyone, and supporting reception staff.
- To reduce stigma: training on substance use and respectful language, sharing positive outcomes, involving staff in a clear plan, and modelling respectful language.
- Offer to help, for example by coordinating with local services.
“I’d agree that some of these patients can be difficult, but say we should keep them since they’re already here, and just not take new ones.”
Accepts the stereotype and still excludes people; no plan for safety or stigma.
“I’d say I understand the incident was frightening and staff need to feel safe. But most of our eight patients have been stable for years, and refusing a whole group because of one person isn’t fair, and it would cut people off from treatment. I’d suggest managing behaviour with the same policy we use for anyone, and some training on substance use and language. I’d offer to help set that up.”
Respects real concerns, challenges the generalisation, proposes fair alternatives, and acts to reduce stigma.
These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.
Ticked: of 5
Tick each item you could do in a real Casper sitting without looking back at this lesson.
- Not yet? Re-read section 1 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 2 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 3 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 3 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 4 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 5 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 6 →
Ready: of 7. Your ticks are not saved.
9. Key takeaways
- See the person before the diagnosis or behaviour; your first sentence should show it.
- Use person-first, non-stigmatising language (“died by suicide”, “a person who uses drugs”).
- In everyday life: notice, ask, listen, connect, and follow up.
- Ask directly about suicidal thoughts; asking gives permission to talk.
- Immediate danger means staying with the person and calling 000.
- Don’t promise secrecy you may not be able to keep; explain the limits honestly.
- Mental health law varies by state but shares principles: voluntary first, least restrictive, rights and participation.
- Harm minimisation means meeting people where they are, without abandoning safety limits.
- Families are vital supports: listen to them, share with consent, and disclose without consent only to prevent serious harm.
- Debrief and look after yourself after confronting situations.
Practice plan
| When | Task |
|---|---|
| Today | Complete the three worked scenarios under time |
| Day 3 | Practise the direct question about suicidal thoughts aloud until it feels natural |
| Day 7 | Four typed and two video scenarios on distress, substance use and stigma |
| Day 14 | Add a ‘reached out to someone’ entry to your experience bank |
| Week before your test | Full mixed mock across all ten lessons |
Your next step
Choose the line that matches your self-ratings and scenario self-checks in this lesson.
References
- Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. National entry assessment. https://www.racgp.org.au/a-career-in-general-practice/become-a-gp/national-entry-assessment (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Office of the Australian Information Commissioner. Guide to health privacy, chapter 3: Using or disclosing health information. https://www.oaic.gov.au/privacy/privacy-guidance-for-organisations-and-government-agencies/health-service-providers/guide-to-health-privacy/chapter-3-using-or-disclosing-health-information (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Everymind. Mindframe guidelines for communicating about suicide, mental ill-health and alcohol and other drugs. https://mindframe.org.au (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Australian Government Department of Health. National Drug Strategy 2017–2026. https://www.health.gov.au/resources/publications/national-drug-strategy-2017-2026 (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Lifeline Australia. Crisis support 13 11 14. https://www.lifeline.org.au (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Prochaska JO, DiClemente CC. Stages and processes of self-change of smoking: toward an integrative model of change. J Consult Clin Psychol 1983;51(3):390–5.
Recommended reading
Dealing with difficult patients is an inevitable aspect of general practice, and it is a key competency assessed in the Situational Judgement Test (SJT) for GP selection. In the SJT, you will encounter scenarios that test your ability to handle challenging patient behaviors while maintaining professionalism, empathy, and effective communication. Difficult patients may present with a range of issues, including non-compliance, unrealistic expectations, aggressive behavior, or a refusal to accept medical advice. It is important to approach these situations with patience, understanding, and clear strategies to ensure the best outcome for both the patient and yourself.
Understanding Difficult Patients
Before addressing how to manage difficult patients, it’s essential to understand why a patient might be perceived as “difficult.” Often, a patient’s behavior is a reflection of underlying emotions, concerns, or unmet needs. For instance, a patient may be frustrated with their health status, anxious about their treatment, or struggling with personal stress. Others may feel misunderstood, neglected, or dismissed by healthcare providers, which can contribute to their challenging behavior. In the SJT, you will be evaluated on your ability to empathize with patients, identify the root cause of their behavior, and adapt your approach accordingly.
Key Strategies for Managing Difficult Patients
- Active Listening: One of the most powerful tools in dealing with difficult patients is active listening. When patients are upset or resistant, they often want to feel heard. Taking the time to listen attentively, without interrupting, can help defuse tension and allow the patient to express their concerns fully. In the SJT, you will be tested on how well you allow patients to voice their frustrations, and whether you show empathy and understanding as they speak.
- Stay Calm and Professional: It is crucial to remain calm and composed when faced with difficult behavior. As a GP, your ability to maintain a professional demeanor, even when confronted with aggression or hostility, is vital. In the SJT, your responses to emotionally charged situations will be assessed. Staying calm will help you think more clearly and maintain control of the situation. Deep breathing, maintaining good posture, and using neutral body language can all help you stay grounded.
- Acknowledge the Patient’s Concerns: Acknowledging a patient’s feelings does not mean agreeing with them, but it does demonstrate that you are empathetic to their perspective. For example, if a patient is upset about a long wait time, you might say, “I understand that the wait was frustrating, and I’m sorry for the delay. Let’s work together to address your concerns now.” This approach shows respect for the patient’s experience, which can often defuse difficult emotions.
- Setting Boundaries: While it’s important to show empathy, there are times when a patient’s behavior may cross a line. In these instances, setting clear, firm boundaries is essential. For example, if a patient is being verbally abusive or aggressive, you must calmly inform them that such behavior is unacceptable and that you are there to help, but only if the conversation remains respectful. The SJT will assess your ability to establish and enforce boundaries without escalating the situation.
- Manage Expectations: Unrealistic expectations are a common issue in general practice. Some patients may expect immediate cures, be resistant to medical advice, or misunderstand the limitations of medicine. One approach to managing unrealistic expectations is to provide clear, honest, and compassionate explanations of their condition, treatment options, and prognosis. For example, you might explain, “I understand that you want immediate results, but the treatment plan we’ve outlined is designed to give the best long-term outcome, even though it may take time.” In the SJT, you will be evaluated on how well you communicate treatment limitations and manage patient expectations without causing frustration or conflict.
Dealing with Non-Compliance
Non-compliance can often lead to frustration for both patients and GPs. Patients may refuse to follow medical advice for a variety of reasons, such as a lack of understanding, fear of side effects, or a belief that the prescribed treatment is unnecessary. As a GP, it’s your job to explore these reasons in a non-judgmental way and work with the patient to find a solution that addresses their concerns while still providing the best medical care. In the SJT, you may be presented with a scenario where a patient refuses a recommended treatment or follow-up, and you will need to demonstrate your ability to have a constructive conversation to explore their reasons and provide alternative options where appropriate.
Managing Aggressive or Hostile Patients
Occasionally, a patient may become aggressive, angry, or hostile, either due to pain, frustration, or underlying emotional issues. In these situations, it is important to stay calm and non-reactive. The first step is to ensure that the patient feels heard and understood. You can acknowledge their emotions by saying, “I can see that you are upset, and I want to help. Let’s talk about what’s bothering you.” It’s also important to keep a safe distance, use open body language, and avoid raising your voice. If necessary, you can call for assistance from colleagues or security to ensure everyone’s safety. In the SJT, you will be assessed on how effectively you manage conflict and ensure that the situation remains safe and productive.
Managing Expectations Around Time and Resources
Patients in general practice often have different expectations regarding the time and resources available for their care. Some may feel their issues require more immediate attention than is possible in a typical appointment, while others may expect additional resources, such as medications or tests. It is important to explain the constraints you are working within and how decisions are made based on clinical guidelines and the needs of other patients. In the SJT, you will be tested on your ability to communicate these limitations effectively while ensuring the patient feels that their concerns are taken seriously. You might say, “I understand that you have multiple concerns, and while we may not be able to address all of them today, I want to ensure we create a plan to address your most pressing issues.”
Documentation and Reflective Practice
Whenever you deal with a difficult patient, it is essential to document the encounter in detail. This includes recording the patient’s concerns, your actions, and any outcomes or follow-up plans. Thorough documentation helps protect both you and the patient, and it serves as a valuable tool for future interactions. Reflecting on difficult encounters is also a key part of professional development. Consider what went well, what could have been improved, and how you can approach similar situations in the future. The SJT will assess your ability to demonstrate professionalism and reflective practice in these scenarios.
Dealing with difficult patients is a skill that every GP must develop. Whether the patient is frustrated, non-compliant, or aggressive, your ability to manage the situation with empathy, professionalism, and clear communication is key to achieving a positive outcome. The SJT will test your competency in these areas, evaluating how well you handle patient behavior, manage expectations, and establish productive relationships, even in challenging circumstances. By practicing active listening, setting boundaries, managing expectations, and using effective communication strategies, you can successfully navigate these situations and provide the best care for your patients. The key is always to remain calm, professional, and focused on finding a solution that benefits the patient and the healthcare system as a whole.