GP Institute of Australia · AGPT selection: the Casper SJT · Lesson 9 of 10
Safety systems: risk, quality improvement, protocols and medication safety
Think like a safe practice: spot risks, improve systems in small steps, understand why protocols exist and when to question them, and help prevent medication harm.
The RACGP national entry assessment is Acuity Insights’ Casper test: 11 scenarios with two open-ended questions each, four answered on video (one minute per question) and seven typed (3.5 minutes for both questions). It assesses nine competencies, not clinical knowledge, so this lesson teaches judgement and communication rather than clinical facts.1
Where are you starting from?
Rate yourself honestly. There are no marks here; each “Not yet” or “Somewhat” points you to the part of this lesson that closes that gap.
I can describe how a practice identifies and manages risk.
I can explain a Plan-Do-Study-Act cycle with an example.
I understand why staff work around protocols and how to respond.
I can name the main areas where medicines cause harm and how to reduce it.
I can decide when to follow a protocol and when to question it.
“Not yet” answers: . Your choices are not saved.
Learning objectives
- Describe risk management and a safety culture in general practice.
- Use a PDSA cycle to propose a practical improvement.
- Explain why protocols exist, why workarounds happen, and how to respond.
- Recognise the high-risk areas of medication safety and practical safeguards.
- Balance efficiency and safety when they conflict.
How this shows up in Casper
- Scenario types: a shortcut or workaround that seems harmless; a protocol that clashes with a patient’s need; a recurring problem nobody fixes; a medication near miss.
- Typical question stems: “How would you respond to what you’ve found?”, “How would you prevent this happening again?”, “How would you balance efficiency and safety?”
- Common trap: either ignoring a risky shortcut to keep the peace, or condemning colleagues without fixing the pressure that caused it.
| ★★★★ | Must master: shapes almost every answer on this theme |
| ★★★★ | High yield: frequent scenario types and common traps |
| ★★★★ | Know the principles: background that sharpens your judgement |
| ★★★★ | Background: context |
Ratings are GP Institute’s editorial judgement, not an official RACGP or Acuity Insights weighting. Any competency can appear in any scenario.
1. Safety culture and risk management ★★★★
A safe general practice is not one where nothing goes wrong. It is one that expects things to go wrong, looks for risks before they cause harm, and learns quickly when they do. The RACGP’s Standards for general practices, which practices are accredited against and whose sixth edition was released in August 2026, set expectations for clinical governance, risk management and quality improvement across the whole practice team.3 For Casper you don’t need the standards’ content; you need the mindset.
| Step | Question | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Identify | What could go wrong? | Abnormal results not followed up when a doctor is away |
| Assess | How likely, and how bad? | Uncommon but potentially serious (missed cancer) |
| Control | What will reduce the risk? | Results routed to a covering doctor; weekly audit of unactioned results |
| Monitor | Is it working? | Track the number of results older than seven days |
| Review | What have we learned? | Discuss at team meetings; adjust the process |
A near miss (an error caught before harm) shows a gap without the cost of harm. Strong answers treat near misses as worth reporting and learning from, not as luck to be forgotten.
2. Quality improvement ★★★★
Quality improvement (QI) is the systematic, continuous effort to make care safer, more effective and more patient-centred. The most widely used method is the Model for Improvement with Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) cycles: test a small change, measure what happens, learn, and adapt.5 Its strength is that it doesn’t wait for a perfect plan. Casper questions such as “how would you prevent this happening again?” reward this kind of thinking: specific, small, measurable, and involving the people who do the work.
| Problem | Small change to test | Measure |
|---|---|---|
| Patients waiting without updates | Reception updates waiting patients every 30 minutes when running late | Complaints about waiting; patient feedback |
| Low cervical screening rates | Recall prompt plus offering self-collection | Screening rate over three months |
| Missed follow-up of results | Daily check of the unactioned-results list | Results older than seven days |
| Interpreters rarely used | Flag preferred language at booking | Interpreted consultations per month |
3. Safety protocols and why people work around them ★★★★
Protocols such as patient identification, infection control, vaccine cold chain, emergency response, result tracking and equipment checks exist because memory and good intentions fail under pressure. Yet staff often work around them, usually not from carelessness but because the protocol is slow, unclear, under-resourced or doesn’t fit real work. A mature answer treats a workaround as information about a system problem, while still stopping any immediate risk.
| Workaround | What it may signal | Better response |
|---|---|---|
| Sharing logins to print scripts or access records | Too few staff or slow systems | Stop it (it breaches security and accountability); fix the workflow |
| Skipping patient identification checks | Time pressure; “we know everyone here” | Re-train; make the check quick; explain why it matters |
| Ignoring an out-of-range fridge alarm | Cost worries; unclear responsibility | Follow the cold-chain breach process; name a responsible person |
| Not using sharps containers or hand hygiene | Equipment not where it’s needed | Move equipment; audit; lead by example |
| Bypassing the emergency trolley check | No one owns the task | Roster and sign-off |
Past luck is not evidence of safety. A strong answer acknowledges the pressure behind the shortcut, but still stops an unsafe practice and fixes the cause.
4. Medication safety ★★★★
Medicines are among the commonest causes of preventable harm in health care. In 2017 the World Health Organization launched its Global Patient Safety Challenge, Medication without harm, and the Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care published Australia’s response in 2020, with priority actions in three flagship areas: inappropriate polypharmacy, high-risk medicines (with a focus on insulin, opioids, anticoagulants and antipsychotics) and transitions of care.4 In general practice these show up daily: older patients on many medicines, opioid prescribing, warfarin dosing, and medication lists that don’t match after hospital discharge.
Swipe to see the whole figure →
| Cause | Safeguard |
|---|---|
| Look-alike, sound-alike names | Confirm indication with the patient; read back |
| Wrong patient | Check identity with approved identifiers every time |
| Incomplete medication list | Reconcile at every transition; ask about over-the-counter and complementary medicines |
| Interruption and fatigue | Protected prescribing time; checklists |
| Patient unsure how to take a medicine | Plain-language instructions and teach-back (lesson 6) |
| Drugs of dependence | Real-time prescription monitoring; consistent practice policies |
When a pharmacist or nurse queries a prescription, the safe reflex is gratitude and checking, not defensiveness. Pharmacists are one of the most important layers of defence in medication safety.
5. When to follow a protocol and when to question it ★★★★
Protocols serve patients; occasionally a protocol and a patient’s needs conflict. Casper may test whether you can respect the purpose of a rule while recognising when rigid application would cause harm, and whether you can tell a sensible exception from an unsafe shortcut.
Recall a process you improved, or a recurring problem you helped fix, at work, university or in a volunteer role. What did you notice, what small change did you try, and how did you know whether it worked? “Describe a time you improved something” is a common prompt.
Think of a time you noticed a shortcut that worried you. Did you say anything? What was the outcome, and what would you do now?
6. Patients as partners in safety ★★★★
Patients and carers are often the first to notice that something is wrong: a tablet that looks different, a result they weren’t told about, a symptom that hasn’t improved. Encouraging them to speak up, giving clear written plans and inviting questions are part of a safety system. In Casper, including the patient or family in a prevention answer (“I’d make sure she knew what result to expect and when to call if she hadn’t heard”) shows you see them as partners.
| Action | Example |
|---|---|
| Tell them what to expect | “You should hear about this result within a week; please call if you don’t.” |
| Give an up-to-date medicines list | A printed list to carry and show at every appointment |
| Invite questions | “What questions do you have about the new tablet?” |
| Ask for feedback | Patient surveys and suggestion boxes acted on visibly |
7. Worked scenarios
Try each scenario under the real time limit before you open the debrief. Your first instinct on the page is what you are training.
Problem-solvingEthicsCollaboration
You are a GP registrar. You arrive at 8 am on the morning of the practice’s busy flu vaccination clinic.
Hannah Price (practice nurse, in her first year): The vaccine fridge log shows it was at 12 degrees for about six hours overnight; the power must have tripped. The flu clinic starts at nine. What should I do?
Steve Morgan (practice manager): They’ll be fine. It was only a bit warm, and replacing the stock would cost thousands. Let’s just start the clinic.
Dr Ana Costa (senior GP): We had a blip like this a couple of years ago and nothing happened.
- How would you respond to Hannah and Steve this morning?
- How would you prevent this happening again?
Open the debrief
What is really going on
A cold-chain breach: vaccines exposed to temperatures outside the recommended range may be less effective, and patients would not know they had received a possibly ineffective vaccine. Cost and a busy clinic create pressure to carry on, supported by a senior’s “nothing happened last time”. The safety-critical step is not to use the vaccines until advice has been obtained.
Perspectives to acknowledge
- Patients: entitled to effective vaccines and to know if there’s doubt.
- Hannah: did the right thing by raising it; needs backing.
- Steve: real cost concerns.
- Dr Costa: experienced, but relying on past luck.
A reasonable approach
- Thank Hannah for raising it.
- Isolate the vaccines and don’t use them until advice is obtained; follow the practice’s cold-chain breach procedure and contact the state or territory immunisation unit as the national guidance requires.
- Explain to Steve and Dr Costa, respectfully, that this is about whether patients are protected, and that the immunisation unit will advise whether stock can be used.
- Reschedule or delay the clinic; tell patients honestly that there’s a short delay.
- Prevention: a power-outage alarm, a named cold-chain officer, clear breach protocol, training, and a review at the team meeting.
“Steve is the manager and Dr Costa is senior, so I’d go ahead with the clinic; it was only a few degrees and probably fine.”
Uses possibly ineffective vaccines without advice, relies on luck, and doesn’t support the nurse.
“I’d thank Hannah, set the vaccines aside and call the state immunisation unit for advice before using any of them. I’d explain to Steve and Dr Costa that we can’t be sure patients would be protected, and the unit will tell us if the stock is usable. We’d delay the clinic and tell patients honestly. Then I’d suggest an alarm, a named cold-chain person, and a team review.”
Safety first, follows the proper process, respectful to colleagues, honest with patients, and fixes the system.
These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.
Ticked: of 5
Problem-solvingCommunicationEthics
Outside work, you volunteer on Sundays at a community kitchen that cooks and delivers about 80 meals to older people living at home.
The kitchen is run by Joan, a much-loved volunteer who has led it for twelve years. You notice that cooked chicken is regularly left on the bench for two or three hours before being portioned, and that the temperature log hasn’t been filled in for weeks. When you mention it, Joan laughs and says she’s “been doing this since before you were born and never made anyone sick”. Two other volunteers privately tell you they’ve been worried too but don’t want to upset her. Several of the people receiving meals are frail and in their nineties.
- How would you respond to Joan?
- How would you help the kitchen improve its food safety?
Open the debrief
What is really going on
A food-safety risk to very vulnerable people, a respected leader relying on experience and past luck, and volunteers afraid to speak up. The aim is to protect the people receiving meals while respecting Joan’s long contribution and bringing her with you.
Perspectives to acknowledge
- Meal recipients: frail and elderly, very vulnerable to food poisoning.
- Joan: deep commitment and pride; may feel criticised.
- Other volunteers: worried but silent.
- The organisation: legal and reputational responsibilities.
A reasonable approach
- Raise it with Joan privately and respectfully, acknowledging her years of service, focusing on the people receiving meals rather than on her.
- Explain the specific concern (time out of refrigeration) and suggest simple changes: portion and refrigerate promptly, fill in the log.
- Offer to help, for example by taking on the temperature log.
- If the risk continues, raise it with the organisation’s coordinator.
- Suggest food-safety refresher training for all volunteers, a simple checklist, and a culture where anyone can raise concerns.
“Joan has done this for years without problems, so I wouldn’t want to upset her. I’d just quietly put the chicken in the fridge myself when I’m there.”
Avoids the conversation, leaves the risk on other days, and doesn’t change the system.
“I’d find a quiet moment with Joan, thank her for everything she’s built, and say I’m worried about the chicken sitting out because our clients are so frail. I’d suggest we portion and refrigerate straight away, and offer to look after the temperature log. If nothing changed, I’d talk to the coordinator. I’d also suggest a short refresher for all of us so anyone feels able to speak up.”
Respectful, focused on the vulnerable, practical help, proportionate escalation, and a culture fix.
These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.
Ticked: of 5
EthicsProblem-solvingCollaboration
You are a GP registrar. The practice is short-staffed and patients often wait days for repeat prescriptions.
You discover that, while a senior GP, Dr Raj Iyer, is on leave, two receptionists have been logging into the prescribing software with his username and password, which he left on a note, to print repeat scripts for regular patients so they don’t run out. The receptionists say Dr Iyer told them it was fine, the patients are grateful, and “they’re only repeats”. One script you see was for a strong opioid.
- How would you respond to what you have found?
- How would you balance efficiency and safety in a busy practice?
Open the debrief
What is really going on
A serious safety and accountability problem: prescriptions are being issued without a doctor’s review, under another doctor’s identity, including a drug of dependence. The receptionists are trying to help patients and believe they had permission; the real cause is under-resourcing and a doctor’s inappropriate instruction. It needs to stop now, without blaming the receptionists, and the underlying access problem needs fixing.
Perspectives to acknowledge
- Patients: need their medicines but also safe prescribing.
- Receptionists: well-intentioned, following an instruction, now exposed.
- Dr Iyer: responsible for sharing his credentials.
- The practice: legal, regulatory and safety exposure.
A reasonable approach
- Ask the receptionists, kindly, to stop issuing scripts now; reassure them you understand why it happened.
- Inform the practice principal or manager today; secure the login.
- Make sure patients who need scripts get them safely: doctors review and issue repeats; prioritise anyone about to run out, especially of high-risk medicines.
- Review the scripts already issued, particularly the opioid, with a senior doctor; seek advice about any reporting obligations.
- Balance: fix the system with a proper repeat-script process, nurse support, protected doctor time, and electronic prescribing workflows.
“The patients need their medicines and Dr Iyer said it was fine, so I’d let it continue until he’s back and then mention it to him.”
Allows unsafe, unaccountable prescribing including opioids to continue.
“I’d kindly ask the receptionists to stop, and say I know they were trying to help. I’d tell the practice principal today and get the login changed. I’d make sure anyone about to run out had their script reviewed and issued by a doctor, and have the opioid script reviewed. For balance, I’d suggest a proper repeat-script system with protected doctor time, so safety doesn’t depend on shortcuts.”
Stops the risk, protects staff from blame, keeps patients safe, escalates properly, and fixes the cause.
These are illustrative patterns, not scripts to memorise: many different responses can score well.
Ticked: of 5
Tick each item you could do in a real Casper sitting without looking back at this lesson.
- Not yet? Re-read section 1 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 2 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 3 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 4 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 4 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 5 →
- Not yet? Re-read section 6 →
Ready: of 7. Your ticks are not saved.
8. Key takeaways
- Safe practices expect errors, look for risks early, and learn fast.
- Near misses are free lessons; report and learn from them.
- Quality improvement uses small, measured tests of change (PDSA), not grand new policies.
- Protocols exist because memory and good intentions fail under pressure.
- Workarounds signal system problems: stop the risk, then fix the cause, without blaming individuals.
- “Nothing happened last time” is luck, not safety.
- Medication harm concentrates in polypharmacy, high-risk medicines and transitions of care.
- Welcome queries from pharmacists and nurses; they are a vital layer of defence.
- Safety-critical protocols are not the place for exceptions; justified exceptions need senior agreement and documentation.
- Patients and carers are partners in safety: tell them what to expect and invite questions.
Practice plan
| When | Task |
|---|---|
| Today | Complete the three worked scenarios under time |
| Day 3 | Write a one-paragraph PDSA proposal for a problem you’ve seen at work |
| Day 7 | Four typed and two video scenarios on shortcuts, protocols and medication safety |
| Day 14 | Add an ‘improved a process’ entry to your experience bank |
| Week before your test | Mixed timed set; check every prevention answer is specific and measurable |
Your next step
Choose the line that matches your self-ratings and scenario self-checks in this lesson.
References
- Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. National entry assessment. https://www.racgp.org.au/a-career-in-general-practice/become-a-gp/national-entry-assessment (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Medical Board of Australia. Good medical practice: a code of conduct for doctors in Australia (effective 1 October 2020). https://www.medicalboard.gov.au/Codes-Guidelines-Policies/Code-of-conduct (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. Standards for general practices, 6th edition (released 26 August 2026). https://www.racgp.org.au/running-a-practice/practice-standards/standards-6th-edition/standards-6th-edition-hub (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care. Medication without harm – WHO Global Patient Safety Challenge: Australia’s response (2020). https://www.safetyandquality.gov.au/sites/default/files/2020-04/medication_without_harm_-_australias_response._january_2020.pdf (accessed 17 Nov 2026).
- Langley GJ, Moen RD, Nolan KM, Nolan TW, Norman CL, Provost LP. The improvement guide: a practical approach to enhancing organizational performance. 2nd ed. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass; 2009.
Recommended reading
- RACGP Standards for general practices (6th edition): the quality improvement and clinical governance sections.3
- Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care, Medication without harm: Australia’s response.4
- Langley and colleagues, The improvement guide: chapters on the Model for Improvement.5
Breaking bad news is one of the most challenging tasks in general practice, and it is a key competency that will be assessed in the Situational Judgement Test (SJT) for GP selection. As a GP, you will inevitably encounter situations where you must deliver difficult or life-altering news to your patients. Whether it’s a serious diagnosis, a chronic condition, or a terminal illness, the way you deliver the news can significantly affect the patient’s emotional well-being and their trust in you as their healthcare provider. In the SJT, you will be evaluated on your ability to approach these conversations with professionalism, empathy, and clear communication.
The Importance of Breaking Bad News
Breaking bad news is a sensitive task that requires not only medical expertise but also strong communication skills and emotional intelligence. How you convey difficult news can affect the patient’s understanding of their condition, their emotional response, and their ability to make informed decisions about their care. In general practice, patients often rely on their GP for support in times of distress. As their primary healthcare provider, you must ensure that they feel heard, understood, and supported throughout the process. The SJT scenarios will assess your capacity to manage the emotional impact of bad news, maintain professionalism, and provide appropriate support and guidance to patients.
The SPIKES Protocol for Breaking Bad News
One widely accepted method for delivering bad news in healthcare is the SPIKES protocol. This framework ensures that you approach these sensitive conversations in a structured, compassionate way. The protocol consists of six key steps:
- S – Setting up the Interview: Before breaking bad news, it is essential to ensure that the environment is appropriate. A private and quiet space is necessary, free from interruptions. The patient should feel comfortable and secure. In the SJT, you may encounter a scenario where you are asked to manage a situation in which you need to set the stage properly for a difficult conversation. A simple way to initiate the conversation might be: “I’d like to talk to you about your test results. Is now a good time?”
- P – Perception: Before delivering the news, it’s important to understand the patient’s perception of their situation. You might begin by asking open-ended questions like, “What do you understand about your condition so far?” or “What are your thoughts on the results we’ve been discussing?” This step helps assess whether the patient has an accurate understanding and allows you to gauge how much information they are ready to hear. In the SJT, you will be evaluated on your ability to assess the patient’s understanding and readiness for bad news.
- I – Invitation: This step involves asking the patient how much information they would like to know. Some patients may prefer a lot of details, while others may want to hear only the basics. For example, you might ask, “How much would you like me to go into the details of your diagnosis?” This respects the patient’s autonomy and prepares them for the conversation. It also ensures that you are not overwhelming the patient with more information than they are ready for. The SJT will assess whether you recognize the need to tailor the depth of the information to the patient’s preferences.
- K – Knowledge: Once you have set the stage and understood the patient’s readiness, it’s time to deliver the bad news. This should be done in clear, simple language, avoiding jargon or overly complex medical terms. It’s important to be direct yet compassionate. For example, instead of saying “We found some abnormalities,” you might say, “The tests have shown that you have cancer.” After delivering the news, give the patient time to process what you’ve said. In the SJT, your ability to communicate clearly, without being too blunt or evasive, will be evaluated.
- E – Empathy: This is an essential component of breaking bad news. It’s important to express empathy by acknowledging the emotional impact of the news and offering your support. Phrases like “I can see this is difficult to hear” or “I understand this is upsetting” validate the patient’s feelings and let them know they are not alone. Empathy helps build trust and ensures the patient feels supported, which is crucial in maintaining a strong patient-provider relationship. The SJT will assess your ability to demonstrate compassion and emotional intelligence in your response.
- S – Strategy and Summary: Finally, it’s essential to provide a clear plan moving forward. This includes explaining the next steps in treatment, referring the patient to specialists if needed, and discussing the options available. It’s important to give the patient time to ask questions and express their concerns. You should summarize the key points and check for understanding to ensure that the patient feels informed. In the SJT, your ability to clearly outline the next steps and provide ongoing support will be evaluated.
Challenges in Breaking Bad News
Breaking bad news in general practice comes with several challenges, and the SJT scenarios may present various complexities. Some common difficulties include:
- Patient Emotional Reactions: Different patients will react to bad news in different ways. Some may be in shock, others may become angry, and some may be tearful or distressed. It’s important to remain calm and offer emotional support. The SJT will assess your ability to manage these reactions in a supportive and professional manner.
- Time Pressure: In general practice, time is often limited, and breaking bad news might need to occur within a short appointment slot. The SJT will test how well you manage your time in these situations, ensuring that you communicate the necessary information effectively without rushing the patient or cutting them off.
- Patient Denial or Resistance: Sometimes, patients may not be ready to accept the news or may be in denial about their condition. This can make the conversation more difficult. In the SJT, you will need to demonstrate your ability to handle resistance and provide further support, offering to follow up in subsequent visits or referring the patient to counseling services.
Practical Tips for Breaking Bad News
To excel in delivering bad news, there are several practical strategies you can adopt:
- Prepare for the Conversation: Think through what you are going to say before you meet with the patient. This will help you to stay focused, avoid jargon, and be clear in your delivery.
- Use Silence Effectively: After delivering bad news, give the patient time to process the information. Silence can be uncomfortable, but it is often necessary for the patient to absorb the information and begin to process their emotions.
- Offer Emotional Support: Acknowledge the emotional weight of the situation. Be present with the patient, listen to their concerns, and offer comfort where appropriate. You might say, “I understand this is a lot to take in right now, and I’m here to help you through it.”
- Follow-Up: Be sure to arrange follow-up appointments to address the patient’s questions and concerns. Breaking bad news is just the beginning of an ongoing process of care and support.
Breaking bad news is one of the most emotionally challenging tasks in general practice, but it is also one of the most important. The ability to deliver difficult information in a compassionate and clear way is a skill that will be assessed in the Situational Judgement Test (SJT). By following the SPIKES protocol and applying effective communication strategies, you can ensure that patients are informed, supported, and empowered to make decisions about their care. Remember, delivering bad news is not just about conveying information—it’s about showing empathy, respecting the patient’s emotional responses, and providing a clear plan for moving forward. The SJT will assess how well you manage these situations, and your ability to balance professionalism with compassion will be key to success.